More computer graphics in the Classic Trilogy? Yes or No?

I think that more computer graghics added to the classic trlogy would make the fight scenes better and the ships look better. The Special Edition was great but I think that more CG's would be great. No offense to Classic Trilogy lovers, for I love them too.

 

I always wanted the Battle of Hoth to be more like that what was originally envisioned. I also felt that the Battle of Hoth was tactically unsound from the Empire's viewpoint, sending in armour without infantry support. So if they were to make the battles more realistic rather than mere mindless CGI displays, then yes, I would be in favour of added CGI if it were to make the scene in question more realistic and dramatic.

 

Well to be fair, a LOT of FX in the OT still look great today - most of the space battles, etc, but I think some of the "ropier" effects (Rancor, ANH sabres) just look silly, so in that case there IS a case for more CG to be inserted. But ONLY when it`s going to add to the film/saga continuity, not just for the sake of it (as George is wont to do).

 

I would definitely welcome more of everything in the battle of Hoth, especially from the Empire.
After viewing the battle of Geonosis, it feels a little.... little.
Anyway, I think that more CG would probably be fantastic, because ILM always does fantastic stuff with it.


not just for the sake of it (as George is wont to do)

No, he isn't.

Cool! A locked thread that I can post in

 

I'm sorry, but here is a thread for things you'd like to see
here is a thread for things that were changed
and here is a thread for things that (probably) will change


and I'm sure there are a few more about this kind of topic