Natalie Portman in EpII

no i meant by the scene with the fireside... y'know??

 

Oh, that one. That one was also designed by Lucas I think. And she might have been uncomfortable, maybe thats why she was a bit 'flat'. Anyways, she did it well, not to mentioned looked well too.

 

yeah...but i liked the way she acted in that scene...whenever Anakin came closer to her, she'd move back...and y;know... er..

 

Yes, she did well. It was kind of un-gentlmanly for Anakin to do that though. He should have done it more subtly

 

what about when she falls out of the transporter and onto a sand dune. A clone comes up and asks her if she's Ok, ten second silence and then a`yes'.

I thought she was a little corny in the love scenes too. Hayden had to work with the same material but he managed to put much more depth into it.

 

How old are you?? I am 23, but you??

 

I kind of liked that scene... we got see more of..y'know.. but who cares about that scene...

As for the love scenes... umm...mace..help me out here...

 

Thats not bad though, it seemed fine to me.

 

I'm 18.

 

I thought Hayden was exceptional. Again, he is another example of someone getting a raw deal from critics who have no clue what perspective to watch the movie from or what the series really is.

Sad

 

The scene where she fell out of the ship was the only dissapointing part as far as acting went.
I think she made up for it when her white outfit got ripped to reveal her nice stomach.

I am 25

 

Here is a hint THEY WERE GREAT!!!
I know some poeple think they were useless, but how else would you portray a love seen, especially since you needed it to make the other trilogy work.

 

me? I'm 24.

maybe she would have been given a better chance to shine if they had included the scene with her mother and sister.
Admittedly she did always have to play a character who was nervous about her life. Still, for a few meeeelion dollars she should be able to do that

 

Maybe... she was still kind of hurt after that fall and she could only say "yes..." And then she wanted to get to the hangar ... humph er hmph... *sighs*

 

Well, anyway you put it, I think there couldn't have been a better actress for the job.

 

but if you look at is.. hehehe... Leia has Padme's hair color... and she has Anakin's nose...i dunno..

 

She still looked so different from Leia though.

 

Yeah, I don't know which one is more realistic in love scenes. Being corny or just some kinda perfect love scene that the critics like. Often the real life is between thos two, and I personally don't
really care which direction they go from real life since both are equally bad/good in terms of being realistic.

If this didn't make any sense to you, I'm sorry. It's just hard to write my thoughts down, especially in english

 

Even for English speaking people its hard. Where ya from??

 

lets put it this way...the love scenes were a bit rushed cause of Anakin. Y'know... He wanted Padme now!

 

I'm from Finland

 

Hey, I wan her now too But still, thats not the real way to do it.

 

Who could blame Anakin for wanting her. I want her, you want her, everyone wants her...

 

cool, what that guys name in you pic???

 

hehehe *sighs* Im at school... lol... I've got one more class to go to... I really wanna go home now!!