Discussion in 'EU Community' started by Adalia-Durron, Jul 3, 2007.
So, let me get this straight? You love NJO, but hate LOTF and TCW?
Yes, I was a little irritated by a few things from NJO, but as a whole, I love it. TCW bugs me because it is completely redoing the Clone Wars and adds things I just don't think are needed, i.e. Mortis. I don't like the plot of LotF and FotJ. everything about the plot of those two series feels completely wrong to me, and I think Denning had way too much influence over the post-NJO in general.
Fair enough. Keep in mind this is a fan club for both so some might disagree. You've stated the reasons etc so now let's discuss the positives of the NJO. Only one negative in my mind, not enough Kyp!
It always comes back to your ex-husband doesn't it
'Scuse me? Ex!?!?
Sorry, keep thinking that lie you told me the other night was going to come true
That would make me the ex honey.......the late ex!
To defend Zeta; this is technically the NJO/LotF fan which could be interpreted as 'The NJO OR LotF fanclub' not the 'NJO AND LotF' fan club. Since there is not a 'fan club' just for NJO, we might as well hang out here!
Yeah, the only reason I am even in this fan club thread is for NJO, not LotF.
For me I only got to read half of NJO. I only got the book right after Star by Star, whatever that was.
Now I got somewhat of a statement/question involving LotF. I'm currently reading Bloodlines and the part where Jacen forms the GAG and starts raiding out Corellians on Coruscant is completely unnecessary especially with Corellians who did nothing. Just because they are Corellian doesn't mean they are automatically gonna go bonkers and rebel against Galactice City. Yes alot of them did but stereotyping them all together into one is just hasty generalization and thinking upon emotion and not logic. My question is, what are your guys' opinions on this subject?
It's unfortunately the normal reaction to actual or anticipated terror or treason events -- I'm thinking here of the British mass internment of Germans and Austrians just after WW2 broke out. Almost all Germans and Austrians, Nazi or not, Jewish or not, were rounded up. Logic in such cases gives way to panic IMHO.
The ironic part is Jacen himself is half Corellian.
Wouldn't he be considered to be from wherever he was born (Coruscant)? Are we pretending that each planet has their own separate race?
Well alot of planets in galaxy do
At least three and probably more.
Sent from the future using psychic implants.
There is precedence, though, Hitler was part Jewish. Let's not forget the American internment of Japanese-Americans, as well.
Weren't there reports of Corellians getting attacked by groups of Coruscantis? Panic makes people do dumb things.
Why wasn't Omas' office doing anything? Where was Coruscanti PD? What were the Jedi doing? I disagree with what Jacen was doing here, but NO ONE else seemed to be doing anything.
Still doesn't justify the fact he was detaining innocent civilians that didn't do anything and weren't planning to do anything
True, but as was discussed, neither the Americans nor the British were justified by what they did. What the GAG did was not without precedence.
At least we didn't kill people in the middle of interrogation
That you and I know of. Neither one of us have any idea of what has gone on at Gitmo or Abu Gharib.
Yes, Jacen lost his temper and killed a prisoner. A prisoner who was an admitted terrorist, had killed tens of Coruscantis and had tried to kill him and his sister years earlier. Jacen did NOT go into her cell with the intent of killing her.
It still doesn't sit right with me
I still can't see how any of the osik in the post-NJO could have happened.
I know for a fact that no detainee has been killed in either of those facilities.
Sent from a Galaxy far away via R2-N6
I read and finished Sacrifice, what an amazing book. Mara's death was so sad, her last line :'( Sad to see her go, she was by far the best character in the book.
Now I'm reading Inferno, I'm like 120 pages into it. Meh, I don't really like it so far.