No, I don't like the idea... I appreciate the point Mr.P is making, but I agree very much with Hew's sentiments earlier in the thread - changing the rules of what is spoiler and NS info just before the movie's release seems like a sure way of creating chaos, and also a good way of changing the very basis of this entire forum; it's a forum where you can talk about AotC only based on officially released info - clear and simple. I firmly believe it should stay this way. If people are afraid of being spoiled when the movie draws near they can leave TFN for a while - it's the only sensible thing to do if you want to avoid danger. I will leave when the last trailer comes out. It's very hard to see what good it would do to make official information cause for banning people from the forum... ? I think the admins would be letting themselves in for more trouble than they deserve. If an official doll comes out in April that says X plays Y who is a Z etc, it WILL be hard to avoid and we know that very well - so let's leave if we don't want to hear it. The admins of TFN must leave something to the individual fan, and I think the line goes right here - every fan must him/herself make a conscious effort to avoid officially released information, this can not be the responsibility of TFN or the forum rules. I just got a bad feeling that this place would get very messy with a change of rules... Mr.P said "If we can't decide, maybe it's time for a split..." Do you mean you expected everyone to come to some sort of agreement on this, or does this rather reflect the fact that this was a given from the moment you put up this thread...? If anything must happen - for the love of God, go with the exclusive HCNS forum idea. But I don't see the point of having another community forum really. Well, at least I get to keep my beloved AotC and EpIII NS forum the way it is if you go with that.