"I didn't understand the attempt at humor with Obiwan's robe landing on 3PO." It's Anakin, whose robe lands on 3-PO. If anybody's voice sounds off, it's Palpatine's. We haven't heard Anakin yet. And the clunkiest part is Palpatine's, "Then it is decided." with Obi-Wan and Yoda's immediate, reluctant acceptance. Otherwise, it was pretty cool. We all knew how short it was going to be.