You should know, what you're doing here is taking the issues TPM has and kicking them into full gear, and making ROTS look like a god. Let me tell you right now, the acting in TPM exceeds ROTS's acting (which is the king of being wooden, "good enough"? Dream on), and ROTJ, while it has its share of problems, at least has a more mature Luke from the whiney one and the one of the best space battles of the whole Saga. The PT's script is terrible all around, period. No getting around that fact. So by proclaiming it to be the best movie of all six, you must mean better than ANH and TESB, no? Best special effects? That's typical and mandatory for the latest Star Wars film. ROTJ had a weak looking Vader? ROTJ has REDEEMING looking Vader. Han Solo's character was simply going through development to becoming a more compassionate person, although I do agree, his character was weakened in ROTJ. Watto was actually okay. No, the acting certainly wasn't Jehovah in the Star Wars saga, but in the OT, it was cheesey, yet it met satisfactory. In the PT, it's stiff, and just downright bad.