Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by Jeff 42, Dec 17, 2003.
If ten isn't leading, SW fans have lost ALL credibility.
I give it 9, only because I believe the Extended Edition on DVD will be even better.
9 for the scene where Legolas attacks the Oliphaunt and kills it.
In my mind, it was utterly ridiculous.
Oh, and also taking out the Gandalf/Saruman scene.
It would be ten, except they copied a scene from Star Wars so that takes off at least one point.
Which scene was that?
I've seen the movie several times...and have never once seen a scene that was "copied" from Star Wars...
EDIT: I gave the movie a 10. Absolutely brilliant.
It will get an "11" once the EE comes-out. A movie that I'm sure will knock ESB out of the top spot as my favorite flick of all-time.
best movie ever
Very good movie, but can get very tedious at times and the ending is so horrible (editing-wise)it completely brings down having watched the movie for me.
They killed Denethor. And Gandalf.
Dude, wherer's the 11?
RotK is definately in my top 5 movie list.
8, great film but defenitley not flawless!
its just not as perfect as the first and just nearly as great as the 2nd!
8, but I think the EE will fix that.
The Two Towers was my favorite book but after Seeing ROTK I read them again and now thats my Favorite, it gets a 10
9 - but I think the SEE will be 10, no doubt: 4,5h of wonderful pictures, great action and not to forget, the massive beheading of ugly orcs (metaphorically).
10, but Star Wars is still much better.
I'll give it a 9. But as I've seen the extended edition on dvd now, and they put Saruman back in, I'll give the extended version 9.5
Since 11 isn't an option I guess I am reluctantly going with 10.
I gave it a 7.
10. Looking at it as a film, and not a page for page adaptation of a book, ROTK is as good as it gets.
A masterpeice but the ending is so drawn out I gave it a 9
Awesome flick. I gave it a 9. In my opinion, though, FOTR was better. That, I would give a 10.