Lit One Canon - Merging Legends and the New Canon - TFA spoilers, very much so

(I know you're joking but) In Aftermath, Tashu, a dark-side cultist, called Luke "incorruptible." I think canon is trying to build a case that it just would not be in Luke's nature to go to the dark side, for any reason.

 

Sinrebirth

Ok I got for yuh. If someone asked this one already I apologize.

Explain Malachor in Rebels and Malachor in KOTOR 2. How does that fit in One Canon.

 

The Malachor in Rebels isn't identified as the fifth planet. Malachor V was destroyed, but the system's other planets probably survived to an extant. Either that or it's like the two Bysses thing.

 

Sinrebirth if Luke does end up being Rey's dad and the mother/wife is not Mara Jade I will definitely be interested to see how you will attempt to try to put those two things into one universe. Luke was a playa.

 

vncredleader And this has been, a one canon explanation.




Sinrebirth I always admire this thread and the creative nature of mixing the two together. It's going to be interesting to see how long we can keep this up the further on we go.

 

I was just thinking about this yesterday. Even if we concede that it was a different planet in the same system, at what point does the epic Jedi vs Sith battle take place? During Kotor 2, before, after?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

As the only Legends work still being continued, I wish The Old Republic would incorporate canon elements into the game to make it feel more relevant to new players (exploring Jedha, Ahch-to, etc). The Scourge of Malachor would make for a very significant in-game event.

 

Oh i'd love to explore Jedah in it's hay day.

Well according to the greatest source of all time WOOKIPEDIA!!!!!!!!!!!!.......The Sith were formed 6000 years before the Clone Wars according to the Canon section.

 

There was a line mentioned by Palpatine in Empire's End, that I wonder if it could tie into Vitiate and the One Canon: Palpatine mentions having seen a game evolve over eons, and the only Sith Lord we knew to have lived centuries was Vitiate.

 

I don't think he's speaking literally. Might just be a bit of dodgy grammar, but it seems pretty likely he's referring to having seen different versions of the game from over the eons. Besides,

Spoiler

that whole conversation is essentially Palpatine embracing the idea that he might die, and what contingencies he puts in place because of that. Not exactly the talk of an immortal Emperor.

 

Good. I didn't like that story at all in Legends EU. I mean Luke's not perfect, no one is, but he didn't go to the dark side for Leia, I can't see anything else pushing him off that ledge.

 

spoilers for Rebels Zero Hour

Spoiler

I always wondered who Thrawn was talking to in his last words in the Thrawn Trilogy "But it was so artistically done..." Was he talking to Pellaeon?

However, with One Canon and the Zero Hour episode of Rebels revealed, I'm going to make a guess that Thrawn was talking to Bendu. Thrawn having the last word against Bendu, so to speak. Bendu said in 2 BBY that he saw Thrawn having "many arms surrounding him in a cold embrace." Thrawn is finally replying in 9 ABY to Bendu that, even so, "it was so artistically done."

 

I was watching Rogue One again, and I noticed how Tarkin justifies his takeover of the Death Star to Krennic by saying that he was the one who presented the original idea to Palpatine years ago. I assume Tarkin is referring to stealing Sienar's idea in Rogue Planet and presenting it to Palpatine as his own? Because I'm not sure what incident Tarkin could be referring to if one goes by Disney canon alone (I haven't finished reading Catalyst or Tarkin, but both of those take place after the Death Star idea was already around in AOTC).

 

Sinrebirth I brought this up some time ago (more of a joke than anything at the time) but I am curious if this event were to play out how you would incorporate it into one universe with all the legends stories. And that is if Rey does end up being Luke's daughter but the mother is someone else other than Mara Jade.

In order to put that into one universe with Luke also being married to Mara Jade is there anyway you could do that without saying that Luke was two timing or that Luke and Mara Jade practiced polygamy?

 

jamminjedi23
Well then it was obviously Luuke the whole time.

 

Rey was born in 15 ABY. This was 4 years before Luke and Mara got together.

 

Who said Luke was married to Rey's mother?

 

True. And this is all just speculation of a scenario that might be true after Ep. VIII. In anycase though I would imagine that if Rey does end up being Luke's kid it will be a daughter through marriage and not just some chick he was having fun with.

 

Stop! I don't need to buy anymore SW books now but you are making me want to!

 

Luke didn't go dark in Dark Empire, according to Chee "he nearly fell". He came pretty close but Leia saved him just as he was about to fall off the edge.