Clone Wars Order 66 on TCW

I mean pretty much after most of the significant Jedi were slain or went into hiding. As in later into the Purge

All I care about is whether or not Ahsoka bites he dust.

I'm interested in her fate. Also interested how some of the clones we've gotten to know, particularly Rex and Fives, react to it. I'm assuming for the most part they'd follow orders like Cody does, but I'd still like to see those two specifically.

Fives was known to disobey orders, Umbara Arc is an example, Rex always follows orders

He might always follow orders, but he doesn't always do his duty as the rules require. He doesn't report Lawquane for desertion, he prevents Dogma and Tup from reporting Fives' plan to Krell, and he agrees with the decision not to execute Jesse and Fives. Rex is willing to disobey orders, though not as quick to do it as Fives is. I think that's part of his arc in the Umbara storyline.

mmm yea i guess ur right

I agree with this completely and think its part of what makes Rex such a fan favorite. I also see this as being why so many are interested in what Rex does when the order is given. I think most people can see Fives disagreeing with and not going through with the order, even if they don't believe this is what will happen. The Umbaran arc made this side of fives quite clear. Of course he could follow through on it like the majority of the clones, but IMO i see fives refusing. Rex on the other hand is the wild card - it really COULD go either way with him.

If he disobeys, I think mot people will be relieved and excited to see what his next step is (if he can disobey and survive long enough for a next step).

If he obeys, I think the explanation of why he does would have to be explored more than it has in the past with; these simple ideas of pre-programmed orders, etc.

The dramatic dilemma should be amazing to watch either way.

In regards to Filoni's comments on exploring Order 66 and Palpatine's not so smooth execution:

Obviously, there's Mauldalore to consider - this definitely wasn't a part of his plan and complicates things a bit. BUT, I think he'll use it beautifully to his advantage. This could be what Filoni meant and I think there's the possibility that its outcome will have major implications through the galaxy - Force sensitives (be it Sith, Dark Jedi or Jedi) are far too dangerous to the safety of the galaxy. I think the season 5 trailer shows us that seeds of distrust for the Jedi are growing within the Republic: "There are some citizens of the Republic who believe the Jedi order is not what it used to be." The Clone Wars have turned the Jedi from keepers of the peace into leaders of armies.

I could see endless possible scenarios for Order 66 to be explored prior to its execution, including Palpatine bringing a potential Jedi threat to the senate publicly. Following the possible fallout from Mauldalore, Palpatine could present the Senate with new contingency orders be passed - including Order 66. He could show how Jedi are too powerful to be taken alive and should a coup occur, all Jedi are to be dealt with lethally.

OR

Order 66 could be slipped into a new law under one of over hundreds of additional provisos and clauses. That way, it could be passed and implicated legally and no one would really know about it. A few senators may read the fine print and discover it odd, bring it to a Jedi or two's attention, start the Jedi temple rumor mill going and by ROTS, the council becomes very suspicious of Palpatine's motives. Its implication wouldn't be made public knowledge but it could be in the form of a high ranking officials debrief on new rules and regulations - a quarterly SOP revisions meeting or what not for GAR clone commanders and captains and possibly even Republic Naval officers.

In the comics Palpatine is fairly unconcerned about all the Jedi running around post Order 66. I wonder how CW or it's spinoff is going to handle it.

I know that the previous explanation was just Clones obeying orders without question (as Lama Su said they would), but TCW undermined that.

My issue was that in ROTS when Order 66 is given, all the clones seem to be on "auto pilot" in responding to Palpatine as "my Lord."

I can't speak for the novels or comics, but never on screen has Palpatine ever been referred to as "lord" except as his Sith persona. On top of that, the concept of a "lord" seems incredibly undemocratic, more akin to a lord/vassal or master/slave relationship. Had Palpatine already declared an Empire and the clones now addressed him as "lord," that would be less conspicuous to me. But so far as the clones would know (under the old explanation), Palpatine is simply informing the clones that there has been a Jedi Rebellion against the Republic, and I thought it was horribly out of place that the clones would just all start calling Palpatine their lord in that moment.

As some kind of brainwashed, subconscious trigger I think it makes more sense - both to reign in the independence the clones have been shown to have in TCW and to account for why Palpatine is their lord all of a sudden.

And if it is a Manchurian Candidate style thing, then Rex and Five's independence would possibly prove irrelevant if their will can be overridden.

If you're looking only at the movies, then we never see the clones address Palpatine in any other fashion. That may very well have been the approved style of address for the troops. It's not all that out of place, considering Padme was referred to as "My lady" numerous times throughout the films, even as a senator. The Revenge of the Sith novel appears to corroborate that with the troopers addressing Bail as "My lord" as well.

Yeah that thing with Tup was strange.

I really hope it isn't brainwashing; the notion of the clones being good guys being forced to do something against their will is nauseating to me. I think that the clones were just following orders faithfully and without question is a much more interesting idea. Don't simplifyit for the kids, don't make evil black and white.

I like the idea they were just following orders too. I could see brainwashing testing being a idea, as a experiment on a few clones. But I don't want all the clones to be brainwashed and forced to act against their will and thats how Order 66 was explained. They were given a order by their leader and followed it.

That makes the stories more interesting when there are Clones who disobey the order.

Maybe Tup was just having a meltdown and after what happened with krell he wanted to take out a jedi? probably not but who knows. I agree, I dont like the brainwashing idea. I liek following orders, then we have a few clones who dont follow the order which i always thought was very interesting. Brainwashing kinda defeats the purpose

"The time has come Cody" definitely makes it seem like the Clones knew about it all along, but that statement can be false after seeing the trailer for season six, because Tup doesn't actually know what's going on with his head, as he's banging it like you do when you get a headache, and his tone changes when he says "A good Clone follows orders". I did find it quite disturbing at the disgruntled tone of his voice when he said "Jedi...", like suddenly the Jedi was the enemy an he didn't care about the Battle Droids anymore.

Fives was shocked when Tup shot the Jedi, and you could tell he definitely didn't know why he did it, so the Clones didn't have any knowledge of Sidious' plans at this point, unless they were all pretending like they had no idea why Tup did it, but that's unlikely. All the evidence is pointing towards mind control, plus as someone else pointed out yesterday, Tup's eyes apparently changed colour, and the last time we saw a Clones eyes change was when they were under mind control from the brain worms.

Sure mind control seems like an odd idea, but I think it might work. I think I'd rather have a different solution where it gives the opportunity to show some of the Clones, like Rex and Fives not wanting to follow Sidious' orders, but I don't know how they are going to be able to do that if mind control is the solution, unless some of the stronger willed Clones can fight it, which would be a very interesting aspect to show. Rex is surely a stronger willed Clone as we've seen throughout five seasons of TCW, because unlike Cody and Wolffe for example, he spends a lot of time with his commanders and has actually gotten to know Anakin and Ahsoka really well, where as Cody and Wolffe have focused more on fighting the battles all the time and getting the job done, sure they care for their commanders, but not as much as some of the 501st.

Yea, I don't really know what I want - I do agree that the film set it up in a very confusing manner. Didn't Traviss' RC novels cover the whole "the time has come" angle and basically come right out and say that it was something that all the clones knew about before hand (I'm thinking of the whole Aayla Secura death). So Traviss comes out in the EU and says it was a previously planned and revealed operation between Palps and the Clones and GL comes out and says it wasn't brainwashing. Then we have the Umbaran arc that shows that they don't always follow Orders and now we have this Tup sequence implying a sort of Manchurian Candidate thing...I don't know what version I like best...

...as long as Fives (and possibly Rex) opposes it and refuses to participate, I'll be happy. Whether that be by a) being ignorant of Palpatine's preemptive plan b) refusing to follow the Orders based on his own judgement c) fighting the "headache" and beating it (being one of the few with strong enough wills to resist it).

I always hope for some sort of situation that would cause Palpatine to draft up the Order within the military as a confidential contingency that he relayed to the commanding Clones later during the war after several incidents (that he manipulated) suggested the need for such a contingency. For example, many Jedi acting out against the chancellor/senate's orders b/c of their ethical ambiguity and being portrayed in the public as "another General Krell." if enough Jedi defied the military takeovers near the end of the war, it could Justify Palpatine calling a top secret military conference to implement the Order if "their suspicions about the Jedi's treasonous actions" were proved true at some point. Then after Windu confronted him and disfigured him in ROTS, he would call the commanders saying "the time has come" i.e. "They have done what we suspected - they're plotting to take over" "Execute Order 66."

Maybe the Tup incident was an experiment to see whether or not he'd be able to control some of the clones who stood up against the Order...it could have worked, or not depending how they paint it...

Everyone should remember we're seeing this clip completely out of context. I know we all love to speculate but it's good to keep that in mind.

Maybe Rex obeys the order for the sheer shock value. Get the audience to care about these characters, believe they are the exceptional guys who don't go along with order 66 and then bam: turns out they're Jedi killers too. Whichever way they go should be interesting.

Ugh. Brainwashing? Really Fioni? Really? I thought that portraying the clones as so individual to start with was a mistake, but this... I don't even think I can find words to describe how horrible an explanation this would be. Come on, cut the BS. We all know that these guys will soon be the bad guy's evil henchmen who get gunned down by the heroes. We know how all these "freedom and individuality" morality tales will end. "Execute Order 66." So show it. These guys will willingly murder their generals after three words from Palpatine and will enforce a brutal regime of slavery, terror, and genocide for over two decades. So show it. They aren't the good guys. They're the bad guys in waiting, at best.

I sincerely hope the context comes up with a good explanation for this, or plot holes big enough to drive a semi truck through will be opening up. Come on guys, TCW already has far too much kiddy crap in it. Let's not add to the list, shall we?