Full Series Reconciling "The Last of the Jedi" with Rebels

Where is Pevra, Todd, and anakinfan?

 

Right okay. I'm stepping in before this conversation goes any further. It's one thing to disagree with people's opinions but don't attack the person over said opinions.

Secondly let's start talking about Filoni instead of each other. Thirdly there isn't anything wrong with Jedi Knight Fett's signature. He doesn't want people to get attacked or bullied but it isn't directed at anyone in particular.

Now, let's move on.

 

Never mind TSF beat me to it.

Anyway Darth Saxman do you not want there to be any light side force users by ROTJ?

 

I just want Luke's story to remain special. That's all.

 

It is special. But that doesn't mean the other stories are not.

 

It would always be special because of several things
Luke is the new hope/Leia
Luke turns back Vader and no one else
Luke is the only person to refuse the dark side in the emperor's face
Luke destroys the death star
Luke is the last Jedi Knight (as of now)

 

Yes, more stories can be told, but certain things need to happen before that star destroyer flies over tatooine in ANH.

 

From Star Wars Novelization:

"“He is here,” Vader stated unemotionally.
Tarkin looked startled. “Obi-wan Kenobi! That’s impossible. What makes you think so?”
“A stirring in the force, of a kind I’ve felt only in the presence of my old master. It is
unmistakable.”
“Surely—surely he must be dead by now.”
Vader hesitated, his assurance suddenly gone. “Perhaps … It is gone now. It was only a brief
sensation.”
“The Jedi are extinct,” declared Tarkin positively. “Their fire was quenched decades ago. You, my
friend, are all that’s left of their ways.”
A comlink buzzed softly for attention. “Yes?” Tarkin acknowledged.
“We have an emergency alert in detention block AA-23.”
“The Princess!” Tarkin yelped, jumping to his feet. Vader whirled, trying to stare through the
walls.
“I knew it—Obi-wan is here. I knew I could not mistake a stirring in the force of such power.”
“Put all sections on alert,” Tarkin ordered through the corn-link Then he turned to stare at Vader.
“If you’re right, he must not be allowed to escape.”
“Escape may not be Obi-wan Kenobi’s intention,” Vader replied, struggling to control his
emotions. “He is the last of the Jedi—and the greatest. The danger he presents to us must not be
underestimated—yet only I can deal with him.” His head snapped around to stare fixedly at Tarkin.
“Alone.”
"
That is canon. That is the way we all knew it up until Rebels and WHOMEVER was responsible for having Jedi running around the galaxy, starting the Rebel Alliance, and running head first into Vader, Inquisitors etc. just a few years before this scene with Tarkin and Vader in Episode IV.

That is an example of explicit canon trampling.

 

We have discussed Tarkin's knowledge of events in the SWU much, much earlier in this thread and Wookipedia disagrees with you BTW. But Tarkin was also wrong there. Yoda was still alive and kicking on Dagobah.... So either Tarkin was wrong or he clearly didn't know everything that was going on in the SWU.

 

But its not because
A. Yoda is still alive so this statement made in ANH is false
And the part on vader is an opinion by him because he is the last of the jedi-and the greatest.

Damn it jabberwalkie you beat me.

 

Aw man, look at it as helping out a friend.

 

This isn't just Tarkin's knowledge --- it is Vader's knowledge and he explicitly is saying that Obi_Wan is the last of the Jedi. Yes, Yoda was on Dagobah and neither of them knew it, but according to Rebels, they both would have known about Kanan, Ezra, and (in later Season 2 episodes) Ahsoka, which would have lead to them never having said any of these lines about Obi-Wan being the last of the Jedi.

Also, what are you talking about regarding Wookiepedia disagreeing with me? Disagreeing with what? I read the page you linked to and have no idea what you're talking about.

Also, folks, can you please go easy on the editing? Just wait until your full thoughts are formulated to post ---- removed.