For me, I could more fairly judge it after the second viewing. I was so overwhelmed during the first viewing, there's no way I could truly take it all in and judge it fairly. I felt like it was a really good film but it was hard to separate the feelings of sadness for what went on during the film and it being the last Star Wars. Seeing it the second time and knowing what to expect, I could sit back and enjoy everything and critique more. This is a great film. I still need to see it more to be able to compare it to the other films, but I think its by far the best of the prequels and somewhere above ROTJ. Although the film ends in darkness, its amazing how well the last couple of shots are able to lift your spirits enough to leave with some feeling of hope. One might say, a new hope even.