I thought it was fantastic-- definitely a few flaws-- but overall I am so happy with it-- and I can't wait to see it again! There was so much to take in that I will need to see it again before I can start dissecting it. I thought everyone in it did a great job-- especially Ian McDiarmid-- how scary-- and R2-D2--how adorable was he? I wish Lucas would have had a few more longer scenes, but since he had that great scene with Palpatine and Anakin in the theater I think I can forigve him somewhat. I think it gives so much more depth to the movie when the actors are really given a chance to act and not lost in quick cuts or special effects.