SWRPF Archive RPG Rating Thread- Approved by PoT

As the name suggests, this is where you rate the RPG's you participate in.

How it works is the author of the game has to put his/her RPG up to be rated. Then, you rate it from one to ten, telling why you rated it that way.

So, I will put my game up to be rated.

Revolt: Year 213

 

Interesting concept babe! Revolt= 9 out of 10. It isn't 10 because sometime ppl don't post or post quickly enough, if that wasn't the case, it would be a 10! Great RPG!

 

B.O.P 10
A.W.O.T 10 my friend is the gm.

 

Monkey_Jedi, what is A.W.O.T.?

I agree with you on BOP. It is such an awesome RPG! Anyone who's RP-ed there will tell you what a great experience it is!

I've never played Revolt...

I give Green Squadron a 10, it's great because you can just play without worrying about all the specifis and mechanics.

 

PoT asked me to make sure that no one rates an RPG unless the author puts it up. Just a note.

 

5 for your rpg its to confusing but i will be rejoining soon.

 

I"m going to put my RPG:

GREEN SQUADRON up for rating.

 

Here is my RPG for Rating:

Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

 

Obi-Wan21, I have to say that color looks absolutely GORGEOUS!

As a GM rep for War Of The Galaxies, I'll let this have a go. Wadda ya all think of our little RPG?

~ DS5

 

Dunno, never played WotG, was planning to start soon, but I heard that its ending soon.

 

I'd personally give your RPG a 8 out of 10. Its a great concept. I would join had I not already gotten involved in too many other RPG's.

 

Here are the RPG's that are up for rating:

Revolt: Year 213
Green Squadron
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
War of the Galaxies

And as there are now multiple games to be rated, please specify which one you are rating.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic[/i]
I give this game a 7.5. It is a very good plot, but has gotten somewhat confusing.

 

As c_c has pointed out guys, just ensure you only give a rating to those threads that are put up for rating by their authors.

If you know of an RPG that you think deserves to get a rave review because you like it so much, PM the GM of that RPG and ask him/her to put his/her RPG up for a rating, and they can then decide to do so if they wish.

Ensure any explanations or criticism are constructive, and to all GMs, enjoy basking in the glory of your RPGs greatness.

I'll refrain from posting my ratings for obvious reasons, but suffice to say I think all of your RPGs are fantastic.

They are what makes this forum what it is: the funkiest and most fun place on the JC forums to hang out and pit your wits against some of the internets most creative, to just have fun, or perhaps relax for a spell.

Have a good rate all you deskbound critics, I bid you adieu.

 

Thank-You Protégé-Of-Thrawn and now time for my rating I give them each both a 7.5 out of 10, for those are some great ideas listed by those GM's. And for their unique story lines to which the players are to follow.

 

Oops! Sorry!

 

My RPG is The Rebellion.

 

RPG's up for rating:

*-new

Revolt: Year 213
Green Squadron
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
War of the Galaxies
The Rebellion*
Iron Fists*
Vengeance*

 

Revolt gets a 10! I love it!
oh and thanks ceci, for your help!
kisses to ya!

 

Green Squadron: 7 out of 10. It's fun, but rather obtuse to newcomers.

The Rebellion: 9 out of 10. Potential.

I would also like to put my own RPG, Iron Fists officially up for review.

 

I hearby place Vengeance up for ratings.

{additional comments by PM would be appreciated, so I can improve the quality of the RP}

 

Rebellion=9 out of 10.
My favorite RPG...for now.

 

Vengeance- 8.5 out of 10. It's got an amazing plot, but it moves slowly sometimes.

 

Vengence gets a 8.5 for a good plot, but like the poster above has said, it is a little slow.

 

Knight of the Old Republic is cracking along nicely - definitely 8/10 material to me (would of got a 10 if there were any recent posts!)

 

Knigts of the Republic gets a vote from me of 9 out of 10