I tend to skip over forum posts on any fan forum for something I like, not just this one, whenever that term (or any 'trope' in general) pops up. The only reason I stopped to read yours is the graphic jumped out at me. I don't care for tropes in general and I agree this one is probably one of the worst. If I like a character, then I like them. If I don't like them, then I don't, and I'm not especially interested in what the writer was intending when creating them. I evaluate a character for themselves and don't make comparisons.