Should future high quality SW games be as canon as the movies?

The gaming industry evolved a lot since Kyle Katarn left the gaming scene. If they would put out something as good as ME i would want it to be D/G level canon. What is your opinion?

Mav Edit: This really isn't an Episode 7 discussion. I'm going to move this to games.

 

Only the films should be cannon.

 

The games should only be known as games.

 

To hell with canon.

 

Even when they are batter cinematic experience then TPM. ME is superior compared to TPM. Better dialogue , better aliens and better story

 

Would you like to see a reimagined jedi order where only gungans can use the force?

 

I would like to see people stop bickering what is canon and what is not and just enjoy whatever piece of franchise suits them most.
Your overly extreme example is wide off the mark.

 

That actually sounds like it could be a crazy fun animation project.

 

I would like to never see the words "Jedi Order" again. Every time I do I involuntarily roll my eyes. I'm obviously an intolerant Anti-EUist.

 

What is your beef with the Order?

 

I enjoy the games. In fact up until about 2005 I only played SW games. In fact I'm playing The Old Republic MMORPG right now.

That said there's some lame elements included in the games that aren't worthy of being canon. Also, the movies shouldn't be shackled to games or EU elements. In order to have the strongest, most exciting story the producers should be able to pick and choose or ignore any element from the EU to include games.

 

Good question. Disregard my post. I'm posting before thinking again.

 

"
That said there's some lame elements included in the games that aren't worthy of being canon. Also, the movies shouldn't be shackled to games or EU elements. "

If they want to they can easily pick an era where there is next to nothing. They are not shackled.

 

The games have been going steadily downhill since 2005 or so. So no.

 

I disagree. By having to pick an era where there is next to nothing the producers would be shackled. Screw EU even the games and make the best movies possible. In fact, I think we're going to see the next series after the ST be set in the times of the Old Republic when there are plenty of Sith and Jedi battling. And KK and co shouldn't be constrained to what has already been released.

 

"The games have been going steadily downhill since 2005 or so. So no.'
We don't know for sure unless we see 1313.

 

I still don't get how they would be shackled. What is the knid of story that they could not do?

 

It's simple really. IF you conceptualize that everything that came before or after the movies is canon -- written in stone -- the producers are shackled. This is how. Say they want to bring Kyle Katarn into the ST. They can't because "it's canon." Kyle Katarn existed before the OT.

IMO the producers should not even consider the EU or games, for that matter, except if there are elements they like. In another thread I said I'd like to see the Mandalorians, Kyle Katarn, Mara Jade and Black Sun in the ST even if those elements are out of place according to the EU.

 

One game, even if it is extremely good, doesn't displace 7 years of lazy Battlefront mooching and the TFU mess. At least not to me.

I mean, seriously. Lucasarts has been a freaking mess for nearly a decade. TFU was apparently "okay", TFU 2 sunk the series. They haven't managed to get off a third Battlefront game, which is insane given that the second one was their best-selling game of all time and is still pretty popular. They haven't pandered to the smaller Bounty Hunter/Republic Commando fanbases, despite Republic Commando 2 speculation STILL popping up as recently as April 2010. Whoever is/was making marketing decisions over there is a moron, especially given how wide-spread popularity is enjoyed by the rest of the EU.

 

edit: nevermind

 

Battlefront was a great game.

 

It's highly unlikely that they would want to use EU characters.

 

Personally, I thought the SOTE project was great back in the day. Though the flip side to that is TFU which is now not considered official canon and falls on the same level as all the other games, books and comics. The TFU is too destructive in my opinion to be canon anyway.

As to future games be considered canon? I don't think so but I do have an open mind... It all depends on the project, the quality, reason behind it and the execution of it... and most importantly: the level of George's involvement. Using a different film franchise as an example; Aliens: Colonial Marines. It is considered to be the official sequel to Aliens and had some involvement and influence from Ridley Scott and several other people that worked on those films. They also hope to even make you see and think differently about Alien 3. The reimagined version of GoldenEye had Daniel Craig... and also had the set designers and script writers from the original GoldenEye film to help 'modernise' the story for this type of Bond.

It has potential but they are two different mediums with different expectations... especially comparing the linearity of films to the multiple levels of interactivity the player experiences/choices in the game format.

 

I was of the impression TFU is pretty much canon anyway given how much input Lucas had in the story. Essentially it was his official bridge between Episodes III & IV, at least in part.