Should Lucas allow someone else to make an EU movie?

Discussion in 'Literature' started by JediQuiTal, Oct 11, 2001.

?

Should Lucas allow someone else to make an EU movie?

Poll closed Mar 22, 2012.
Yes 34 vote(s) 38.2%
No 39 vote(s) 43.8%
Depends on the Crew 16 vote(s) 18.0%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. JediQuiTal Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Dec 18, 2000
    star 1
  2. Cowboy_Jedi Jedi Youngling

    Member Since:
    Aug 20, 2001
    star 2
  3. JediQuiTal Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Dec 18, 2000
    star 1
    I mean, I have an extreme ability to direct, run audio, and edit. I could easily right an "Heir to the Empire" movie. It would be awesome!!!
  4. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    Personally I don't think it should be a movie. I've always felt the EU would make an excellent TV series. You could break down a book into 2 or 3 hour-long episodes, spread out over a 22 episode season. You could probably cover 2 trilogies+ per season, or, actually, could probably fit the whole X-Wing series into a season. That could follow up with the Thrawn trilogy and Dark Empire/DE2 for the next season, then the JAT/I, Jedi/Callista trilogy for season 3, BFC and Corellian trilogies for the fourth season and then, perhaps, the fifth season would be the Hand of Thrawn duology and Union with a season cliff hanger of Vector Prime.

    They'd obviously have to recast the heros from the film, but maybe a couple could return (Denis Lawson for Wedge, for example).

    Perhaps they could break up the trilogies with stand-alone episodes based on some of the anthologies and short stories.

    I think it would be a great treat for the EU fans as well as a way to introduce the EU to new audiences. And since it would be a TV series, the canon-purists could still ignore the TV series and claim only the movies counted.

    Most importantly though, would be that it would help carry Star Wars in the public awareness beyond Episode 3 and help sustain it for another 20 years.
  5. Vaderbait Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    Sep 26, 2001
    star 6
    No, the beauty of Star Wars is that it is a story. The EU is not part of that story, it branches off, Wars isn't Trek. (I like Trek though).

    The movies have six episodes, and the story ends. The EU, though I don't like it, does expand on that, but it shouldn't become a movie or TV series. That's canon territory.

    Episode I story begins
    Episode VI story ends
    EU, spans before and after, not meant to be made into movies
  6. PrinceXizor Former TF.N Foreign Book Cover Staff

    VIP
    Member Since:
    Jul 4, 2001
    star 5
    I'd enjoy a TV series, but I think there should be no more movies.
  7. Neo_Jedi Jedi Padawan

    Member Since:
    Sep 19, 2001
    no, he should NOT let ANYONE make ANYMORE movies. they need a cartoon seriessci fi nut agreesin a thread about turning books into movies or something... anyway, a good fighter cartoons series would be great, or an adult anime NJO series.
    and vaderbait, didnt george originally plan 9 movies? i think that in itself says that ep VI does not end the story. plus, a lot was left unsaid at the end of jedi. yeah, the destruction of the second death star was extremely devastating, and the empire did die this time, you would still have to be naive to think thats the end of the empire,.. leavin room for 7-8-9, which was taken place of by the EU. the movies showed leia had force potential, but didnt expand on that AT ALL. what about leia and han? where does luke and the future of the jedi go from here? im sure the list goes on. u say thats not meant to be a movie, and if thats not, then i cant figure out what the HELL importance ep 1 had, except the introductin of characters and ideas.
    personally, i think finishing off the characters stories is a little more important than showing how the empire rose to power.
    just some food for thought
  8. yoda_does_dallas Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    May 11, 2001
    star 1
    No, no movies and no series. Even though an X-Wing Tv series might seem good it would be so watered down for Tv that it would ruin the fantasy for most people
  9. ShadesOfGrey Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Sep 10, 2001
    I agree with Yoda_does_dallas, a TV series would seem really watered down and never live up to the movies. It would all seem so small, and well on a small budget.
  10. Arabwel Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Sep 20, 2001
    star 2
    The2ndQuest (did I get the name right) has a great idea. It would be wonderful!

    EEk, gotta go!

    Ara
    (Almost late for class.... goes now!)
  11. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    You got it right::)

    Yeah, personally, I think it'd be a great idea and you'd probably be able to fit the major/essential EU stories into 5 years and then NJO could get a whole season to itself.

    Plus, the way I see it, there would be no harm. Afterall, once Episode 3 is out, Star Wars is basicly over. There will be no more films. All that will be left is Expanded Universe materials such as the novels and comics, so if that is all there will left of Star Wars once the movies are done, why not cater to and support that market?

    I don't think it would be a problem as far as canon goes, because since they would always be extensions of the books and comics, those who ignore them can continue to do so. And, afterall, how many TV series are considered "official" extensions of the films they are usually based on? Not many.

    I agree an animated adult/anime styled series would be cool, but let's face it, those space battles just wouldn't be the same if they weren't CGI or models. Besides, at this point, CGI can get real good quality at a lower cost. Hell, look at Babylon 5's later seasons. They were able to do that quality 4 or 5 years ago on a low budget, imagine what you could do today with all the advances in CGI technology- just look at the various Star Wars/B5/Trek fan films and several have pretty great quality effects work on a next to nothing budget. I could only imagine professionals could do just as well if not better.

    And from a marketing stand point, like i said above, if all that remains (as far as new content is concerned) of Star Wars after episode 3 will be the EU, why not exploit that?

    Besides, Lucas probably wouldn't mind having a TV series to test out new film technologies on like he did with the Young Indy Chronicles (where they first experimented with several effects techniques that were later used for the prequels and other ILM-effects films).
  12. PrinceXizor Former TF.N Foreign Book Cover Staff

    VIP
    Member Since:
    Jul 4, 2001
    star 5
    The2ndQuest : A TV series'd be great but your adaptation doesn't fit with all the material available. Doing that in 5 seasons would only result in a too loose adaptation, and people wouldn't be able to follow very well what happens. Adapt the whole EU correctly would take a lot of seasons, far more than 5 seasons.
  13. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    Well, I was basing that on the idea that each book would be adapted into a 2 or 3 hour script, spread out over 2 or 3 episode, each an hour in length. You'd obviously have to trim or rewrite some material to fit within that timeframe. But thats the way with any book adaptation. And like I said above, if it is, say, 3 episodes per book- you'd be able to fit a trilogy into 9 episodes. You could do another trilogy in that same time span bringing it to 18 episodes. Assuming you are working with a 22 episode season, that leaves 4 more episodes to either do a stand-alone book (ala Shadow Hunter or Truce at Bakura) or several single-episode stories based on the Anthologies or other short story collections.

    So, if you have 2+ trilogies per season, in five seasons you could do the equivilent to ten trilogies + 20 single-book or single-episode stories.

    I think that would be ample enough space to present the "essential" expanded universe in a live action format. You'd probably have room left to work in some new tie-in material to bridge the various trilogies.
  14. PrinceXizor Former TF.N Foreign Book Cover Staff

    VIP
    Member Since:
    Jul 4, 2001
    star 5
    Hmmm... Well, it seems indeed correct. But as I said, I think it'd be too stretched, not enough 'continuous', which is quite a basic need for a series. That's why I think a RS TV show'd be great. (See my post about that there for more details...)
  15. Darth_Kevin Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    Aug 30, 2001
    star 5
    Why not a CGI animated series for the novels and stories. You still get cool special effects, plus you have the benefits of CGI-animating the main characters so they can look a lot like they're film counterparts.

    An X-Wing series would be awesome, kind of like Black Sheep Squadron in a GFFA.

    I like the idea of season story arcs as well:

    Seasons 1 & 2 - SOTE, Bakura & X-Wing

    Season 3 - Courtship, Thrawn trilogy, DE
    - add bridge stories in between for TTT to DE, DE to DEII (Lightsider), and EE to Jedi Academy

    Season 4-5 - Rest of Bantam novels/stories
    - requires bridge stories as well
    - SotP/VotF finale

    Season 6 - YJK and JJK

    Season 7-8 - NJO

    Season 0 - The two Han Solo Trilogies
    - prequel to ANH season

    Also, I think TOTJ and Droids comics could work well as animated series. TOTJ is so far away from the films chronologically, there's a lot more freedom for additional stories besides the comic books.

    The main problem is that if any of these shows took off, there's only a limited amount of EU material in existence for adaptation. I expect filler episodes to be necessary, and I doubt TV-writers have ever delt with restrictions as stringent as those placed by LFL on the stories.
  16. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    (part 1 of 2)

    You're right about it not feeling quite as continuous, but there are ways to do semi-anthology shows properly. I imagine setting a time frame prior to each episode would help viewers place things in their mind. The show could be called Star Wars Tales, SW Chronicles, SW Universe, etc to imply this.

    Ok, I'm gonna post this in both this thread and the other related one to cover all my bases (All your base belong to...sorry[face_batting] )

    This is an example of how an EU TV series could pan out as a semi-anthology epic series.


    2 Hour Premiere- Dark Forces: Soldier for the Empire

    Season 1- "Birth of the New Republic"

    Episode 1- Shadows of the Empire, part 1
    Episode 2- Shadows of the Empire, part 2
    Episode 3- Shadows of the Empire, part 3
    Episode 4- The Truce at Bakura, part 1
    Episode 5- The Truce at Bakura, part 2
    Episode 6- Dark Forces: Rebel Agent, part 1
    Episode 7- Dark Forces: Rebel Agent, part 2
    Episode 8- Dark Forces: Jedi Knight, part 1
    Episode 9- Dark Forces: Jedi Knight, part 2
    Episode 10- Twin Engines of Destruction
    Episode 11- X-Wing: Rogue Squadron, part 1
    Episode 12- X-Wing: Rogue Squadron, part 2
    Episode 13- X-Wing: Rogue Squadron, part 3
    Episode 14- X-Wing: Wedge's Gamble, part 1
    Episode 15- X-Wing: Wedge's Gamble, part 2
    Episode 16- X-Wing: Wedge's Gamble, part 3
    Episode 17- X-Wing: The Krytos Trap, part 1
    Episode 18- X-Wing: The Krytos Trap, part 2
    Episode 19- X-Wing: The Krytos Trap, part 3
    Episode 20- X-Wing: The Bacta War, part 1
    Episode 21- X-Wing: The Bacta War, part 2
    Episode 22- X-Wing: The Bacta War, part 3

    2 Hour Special- Darth Maul: Shadow Hunter

    Season 2- "Empire Resurgent"

    Episode 1- X-Wing: Wraith Squadron, part 1
    Episode 2- X-Wing: Wraith Squadron, part 2
    Episode 3- X-Wing: Wraith Squadron, part 3
    Episode 4- X-Wing: Iron Fist, part 1
    Episode 5- X-Wing: Iron Fist, part 2
    Episode 6- X-Wing: Iron Fist, part 3
    Episode 7- X-Wing: Solo Command, part 1
    Episode 8- X-Wing: Solo Command, part 2
    Episode 9- X-Wing: Solo Command, part 3
    Episode 10- Courtship of Princess Leia
    Episode 11- Heir to the Empire, part 1
    Episode 12- Heir to the Empire, part 2
    Episode 13- Heir to the Empire, part 3
    Episode 14- Dark Force Rising, part 1
    Episode 15- Dark Force Rising, part 2
    Episode 16- Dark Force Rising, part 3
    Episode 17- The Last Command, part 1
    Episode 18- The Last Command, part 2
    Episode 19- The Last Command, part 3
    Episode 20- X-Wing: Isard's Revenge, part 1
    Episode 21- X-Wing: Isard's Revenge, part 2
    Episode 22- X-Wing: Isard's Revenge, part 3

    2 Hour Special- (An Episode 2/Episode 3-era story)

    Season 3- "The New Guardians of Peace and Justice"

    Episode 1- Dark Empire, part 1
    Episode 2- Dark Empire, part 2
    Episode 3- Dark Empire ][, part 1
    Episode 4- Dark Empire ][, part 2
    Episode 5- Empire's End
    Episode 6- Crimson Empire
    Episode 7- I, Jedi/Jedi Search, part 1
    Episode 8- I, Jedi/Jedi Search, part 2
    Episode 9- I, Jedi/Jedi Search, part 3
    Episode 10- I, Jedi/Dark Apprentice, part 1
    Episode 11- I, Jedi/Dark Apprentice, part 2
    Episode 12- I, Jedi/Dark Apprentice, part 3
    Episode 13- I, Jedi/Champions of the Force, part 1
    Episode 14- I, Jedi/Champions of the Force, part 2
    Episode 15- I, Jedi/Champions of the Force, part 3
    Episode 16- Children of the Jedi
    Episode 17- Darksaber, part 1
    Episode 18- Darksaber, part 2
    Episode 19- Darksaber, part 3
    Episode 20- X-Wing: Starfighters of Adumar, part 1
    Episode 21- X-Wing: Starfighters of Adumar, part 2
    Episode 22- X-Wing: Starfighters of Adumar, part 3

    2 Hour Special- TIE Fighter

    Season 4- "End of an Era"

    Episode 1- Before the Storm, part 1
    Episode 2- Before the Storm, part 2
    Episode 3- Before the Storm, part 3
    Episode 4- Shield of Lies, part 1
    Episode 5- Shield of Lies, part 2
    Episode 6- Shield of Lies, part 3
    Episode 7- Tyrant's Test, part 1
    Episode 8- Tyrant's Test, part 2
    Episode 9- Ambush at Corellia, part 1
    Episode 10- Ambush at Corellia, part 2
    Episode 11- Assault at Selonia, part 1
    Episode 12- Assault at Selonia,
  17. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    (2 of 2)

    Season 5- "The New Jedi Order"

    Episode 1- Vector Prime, part 1
    Episode 2- Vector Prime, part 2
    Episode 3- Vector Prime, part 3
    Episode 4- Dark Tide: Onslaught, part 1
    Episode 5- Dark Tide: Onslaught, part 2
    Episode 6- Dark Tide: Ruin, part 1
    Episode 7- Dark Tide: Ruin, part 2
    Episode 8- Dark Tide: Ruin, part 3
    Episode 9- Agents of Chaos: Hero's Trial, part 1
    Episode 10- Agents of Chaos: Hero's Trial, part 2
    Episode 11- Agents of Chaos: Hero's Trial, part 1
    Episode 12- Agents of Chaos: Hero's Trial, part 2
    Episode 13- Balance Point, part 1
    Episode 14- Balance Point, part 2
    Episode 15- Balance Point, part 3
    Episode 16- Edge of Victory: Conquest, part 1
    Episode 17- Edge of Victory: Conquest, part 2
    Episode 18- Edge of Victory: Rebirth, part 1
    Episode 19- Edge of Victory: Rebirth, part 2
    Episode 20- Star By Star, part 1
    Episode 21- Star By Star, part 2
    Episode 22- Star By Star, part 3

    2 Hour Special- "Dark Journey"

    Season 6- "Balance of the Force"

    Episode 1- Enemy Lines: Rebel Dream, part 1
    Episode 2- Enemy Lines: Rebel Dream, part 2
    Episode 3- Enemy Lines: Rebel Stand, part 1
    Episode 4- Enemy Lines: Rebel Stand, part 2
    Episode 5- Traitor, part 1
    Episode 6- Traitor, part 2
    Episode 7- Traitor, part 3
    Episode 8- Destiny's Road, part 1
    Episode 9- Destiny's Road, part 2
    Episode 10- Destiny's Road, part 3
    Episode 11- Force Heretic : Remnant, part 1
    Episode 12- Force Heretic : Remnant, part 2
    Episode 13- Force Heretic : Refugee, part 1
    Episode 14- Force Heretic : Refugee, part 2
    Episode 15- Force Heretic : Reunion, part 1
    Episode 16- Force Heretic : Reunion, part 2
    Episode 17- (New Jedi Order Final Paperback to be Announced), part 1
    Episode 18- (New Jedi Order Final Paperback to be Announced), part 2
    Episode 19- (New Jedi Order Final Paperback to be Announced), part 3
    Episode 20- (New Jedi Order Final Hardcover to be Announced), part 1
    Episode 21- (New Jedi Order Final Hardcover to be Announced), part 2
    Episode 22- (New Jedi Order Final Hardcover to be Announced), part 3

    2 Hour Special- Either "Young Jedi Knights 2" OR "Rebel Alliance" (Tell the tale of the Death Star plans and the early days of the alliance, tying in the story with both Soldier for the Empire, material from the ANH Radio Drama and then end with a lead-in to A New Hope itself)

    (If a seventh season is possible [and why not, freakin' Voyager got 7 years, why can't we?] I would suggest doing "Tales of the Jedi" era stories as I map out below and makes things come full circle with the Jedi vs Sith...but you could also concievably go for post-NJO stories as well)-

    Season 7- "Tales of the Jedi"

    Episode 1- Golden Age of the Sith, part 1
    Episode 2- Golden Age of the Sith, part 2
    Episode 3- Golden Age of the Sith, part 3
    Episode 4- Fall of the Sith Empire, part 1
    Episode 5- Fall of the Sith Empire, part 2
    Episode 6- Fall of the Sith Empire, part 3
    Episode 7- Knights of the Old Republic, part 1
    Episode 8- Knights of the Old Republic, part 2
    Episode 9- Knights of the Old Republic, part 3
    Episode 10- The Freedon Nadd Uprising
    Episode 11- Dark Lords of the Sith, part 1
    Episode 12- Dark Lords of the Sith, part 2
    Episode 13- Dark Lords of the Sith, part 3
    Episode 14- Dark Lords of the Sith, part 4
    Episode 15- The Sith War, part 1
    Episode 16- The Sith War, part 2
    Episode 17- The Sith War, part 3
    Episode 18- The Sith War, part 4
    Episode 19- Redemption, part 1
    Episode 20- Redemption, part 2
    Episode 21- Redemption, part 3
    Episode 22- Redemption, part 4

    2 Hour special- Jedi vs. Sith

    If there was to be a Season 8 or beyond, I would suggest Episode 1-era EU or, again, whatever is post-NJO...but I think 7 seasons would be more than sufficient.
  18. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    I wanted to add also that I mapped all that out simple to give an example of one way you could spread out the EU in a way that works well as a whole but can also be taken on a season-by-season basis (I tried to illustrate this by choosing appropriate places to end a season at and start the next from).

    Now, obviously, some stories may end up longer than others, so in many ways, that concept blueprint above can be altered to give some stories additional episodes and other stories fewer. Heck, many could probably be shortened to 2 episodes even though I've planned for 3. That would make excellent room for pure-anthology episodes based upon the short stories published in various forms (gamer, tales, anthology, etc) or even some other one-shots such as Enemy of the Empire, etc.

    I also again apologzie for the redundant postings to both threads but I figure I'd cover all my ground with this one since i bothered to lay everything out.
  19. Rogue-Jedi Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    May 2, 2001
    star 1
    Nice ideas Quest!

    I don't think SotE should be in the series, as it's before RotJ. Put it out on Video though.

    You're gonna have difficulties with I, Jedi and Academy Trilogy, as they cover different amounts of time span, and have slight contradictions (i tihnk, i actually haven't read Academy Trilogy)

    Very good, but what would happen if I missed an episode!!! :)
  20. The2ndQuest Tri-Mod With a Mouth

    Manager
    Member Since:
    Jan 27, 2000
    star 10
    >>Nice ideas Quest!<<

    thanks

    >>I don't think SotE should be in the series, as it's before RotJ. Put it out on Video though. <<

    Well, with SFTE and SOTE, they do take place prior to ROTJ, but I figure it would be good to start the series on familiar ground during the classic trilogy. It also meshes well with the idea of a semi-anthology and sets the stage for future episodes to tell tales that take place during the films as well. SOTE also sets up Black Sun and makes a logical connection between ESB and ROTJ. However, I could see the decision to do entirely post-ROTJ stories could be valid. But then SOTE seems to be enjoyed alot by people (and I'm certain some people on these boards wouldn't have any objections of seeing Xizor[face_batting] ) so it would be a good way of getting things off to a good start.

    >>You're gonna have difficulties with I, Jedi and Academy Trilogy, as they cover different amounts of time span, and have slight contradictions (i tihnk, i actually haven't read Academy Trilogy) <<

    Well, that's why I listed "I, Jedi" at the same time as the JAT. The series could integrate the two (starting with Corran Horn's part prior to JAT, and then go into Jedi Search, integrating Horn's parts throughout the whole series, and then following Horn's adventures after the events in JAT.) I, Jedi would essentially become the bookend story to the JAT, with parts added to the middle.

    >>Very good, but what would happen if I missed an episode!!! :) <<

    Well, you'd have to wait for the DVD, I guess...but then, as Star Wars fans, that's something we're used to, isn't it?::D

    There's always reruns[face_batting]

    ...or you could just read the books again;;D
  21. Bogga Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    Jul 12, 1998
    star 4
    No, there should at least never be movie versions of the books. What's the last book that has been turned into a movie and been good? The LotR series might be the first. I could never imagine all the info from one of the X-Wing novels being squeezed into anything less than 4 straight hours without commercials. These stories were written in novel form because there's so much to tell.
  22. ron corless Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Dec 1, 1999
    star 3
    I think it would be fun if there were an EU
    movie or a TV series. The first season would
    be the the adventures of Young Han Solo like
    the Indiana Jones Chronicles. The second season would be the Thrawn Trilogy and the
    Bantam Era,the third season would cover NJO
    and the fourth season would cover post-NJO
    and the adventures of Ben Skywalker. Maybe
    there could be a season about the time period between Episode III and ANH dealing
    with the adventures of Darth Vader and how
    he kills the Jedi and the Empire spreads
    across the galaxy. Maybe it could happen in
    the fall of 2005-2006 after the release of
    Episode III.
  23. ron corless Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Dec 1, 1999
    star 3
    Here's my rundown of a SW TV series:

    Season One:The adventures of Young Han Solo

    Season Two:The adventures of Luke,Leia and
    Han between ANH and TESB

    Season Three:Shadows of the Empire

    Season Four:The post-ROTJ era including the
    Thrawn Trilogy,the Jedi Academy Trilogy and
    the Hand of Thrawn books

    Season five:The Young Jedi Knights books

    Season six:NJO

    Season seven:post-NJO and the adventures of
    Ben Skywalker

    Season eight:prequel set between Episode III
    and ANH about Darth Vader and the Jedi extermination

    Season nine:Tales of the Jedi

    Season ten:set 5,000 years after ROTJ about
    a third or fourth Galactic Republic and
    millions of Jedi spread across the galaxy
    and travel to other galaxies is commonplace.
  24. yoda_does_dallas Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    May 11, 2001
    star 1
    "Why not a CGI animated series for the novels and stories. You still get cool special effects, plus you have the benefits of CGI-animating the main characters so they can look a lot like they're film counterparts."

    The problem with this is that you would end up having to pay the original actors a large sum of money to use their likeness even if it is CGI. This would be in the case of Mr. Ford specially, since I don´t see Mr. Hamill getting the big roles anyway.
  25. Rebecca191 Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    Nov 2, 1999
    star 6
    Yeah, no movie, but a TV show would be fun. As long as it's not like the Holiday Special, which I have never seen but read the script of.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.