Maybe we should rename this thread "ROTS Plothole Debate". I would not complain. In my opinion, the holocron scene in ROTS novel made a lot of sense. There should have been some mention of holocrons instead of Anakin just blurting out that's outrageous with no real indication, of why being on the council but not a master, is such a problem. It just seemed random to me in the movie. Also Stover's Anakin had a great sense of humor, even in that scene, replying internally with -Go ahead and Vaapad this, you...!- I think all in all, Stover's Anakin was portrayed as much more likable. Of course, the issue is that Jedi Holocrons are an EU invention, aren't they*? If there was any actual mention of Holocrons in the movies, people would been confused as to what those were. (*Never mind they are pretty canon now since they were mentioned in TCW) As for Luke's love life/On Topic: Luke's relationships tend to end in horrible disaster. (At least in the EU). I find it hilarious so this is why I vote single.