Skinny Hayden vs. Buff Hayden

Which of his looks do you prefer: skinny in AOTC, or filled out in ROTS? Please list reasons why you like your choice as well. Pictures would be nice as well. ^_^


As for me, I prefer buff Anakin; I think he looks more attractive rather than too thin like he was. He just looks the part of Darth Vader better in Episode III.

 

Now, I am a heterosexual male, so I have no real opinion on the matter, but it seems to me that girls prefer buff to skinny as the general rule.



Mace Windy,
too windy for spoilers!

 

Yeah, sadly enough I should know this from experience...

They like buff men...not skinny ones...

 

Windy: I am a heterosexual male as well, but I don't think there's anything wrong with saying another guy is attractive, is there? Besides, this thread was geared towards the females on the board anyway.


So they generally prefer buff to skinny? I never knew that; it'll be interesting to hear opinions when the girls get here.

 

You didn't know that?

You must be buff...or lucky.



Mace Windy,
too windy for spoilers!

 

Well, I'm not buff like a bodybuilder; not even anywhere near close actually. Honestly, I went through the same thing that Hayden went through: In 2002, I was very skinny, and by 2004 (well, now 2005), I've "filled out", so to speak, as Hayden did. Actually, now that I think about it, people (especially girls ^_^ ) have told me I look "cuter" now then I did when I was skinny. Must be my delvings into the dark side......and I'm sure McDonald's helped along the way!


Oh, and could someone post pictures of Hayden in AOTC and ROTS, like a before/after comparison picture? That would be swell.

 

The funniest thing is that it's pretty much agreed on that men look better when they get older, and women look worse.

Unless they drink too much beer like me.

[image=http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/hottopics/alcohol/images/beerbelly.jpg]

Or you're Anakin Skywalker.

[image=http://www.jsonline.com/enter/sw/images/anakin.jpg]

For comparision:

AOTC: [image=http://www.cswu.cz/swfashion/anakin-h11.jpg]

ROTS: [image=http://www.kinofans.com/mat/news/star_wars/epi-3-anakin.jpg]

 

Another difference is Anakin's padawan haircut vs. his own style. I know that women dig a lot of hair - at least on the head. A buddy of mine with very long curly hair honestly beats them off with a stick...

 

I agree about his hair, it looks alot better than Episode II. The WebDoc that showed George and Hayden discussing his hair was awesome.

 

[image=http://mitglied.lycos.de/a041014/04.12.31.%20Sylvester/images/DSC00414.jpg]

Any takers? Austrian girls don't seem to be too thrilled.

P.S.: I hope my gesture isn't offending.

Hayden looks very buff but not enough in the Vader suit- probably due to the one piece should amor. Anyway, there is a big time gap between ROTS and ANH and he aged- so it's no biggy.

 

Billy, maybe if you didn't drink such a wussy drink, they would be more impressed.



*waits for fangirls to come in & drool*

 

A wussy drink?!
That's the Dinos I'm sitting in. The Rat Pack and Jazz bar, Nothing wussy about that.

 

Billy probably reminds girls of a little boy...go by Bill...not that I know much about what girls want

 

But Billy Dee Williams is no little boy. Besides, my real name is Matthew.

Anyway, I wonder if Hayden will be as much of a girls magnet in ROTS just like in AOTC. I somewhat doubt it as he'll be rather creepy. Especially when he is burnt by the lava.

 

Billy_Dee_Binks, you have the hair, but you ain't got the man-flesh, buff, however it's called. And yes, he will be a chick magnet, it's all about the scars, after all chicks dig that (at least I dig Vader's).

I know this sounds shallow but we are being asked about physical appearence. I think both Anakins are nice (and extremely attractive) in their own way.. but Buff!Anakin is just plain sexier, Hayden looks more mature, in control Also chicks dig scars (see above) and that scar around his eye - TEH hotness. And don't get me started on the thighs

 

I'm glad to have a girl's opinion on this!

Any more pictures to offer?

 

Of who?

 

Now, I'm a heterosexual male but, from the standpoint I view Anakin which is being the chosen one and building up to the fall to Vader so I think the buff works better.

 

"Anyway, I wonder if Hayden will be as much of a girls magnet in ROTS just like in AOTC. I somewhat doubt it as he'll be rather creepy. Especially when he is burnt by the lava."

Heh, just ask Mara...

 

Hayden looks much better than the skinny kid in AOTC. But he was cute too then. It's nice to see how he's managed to mature from that film to this one. I also think it make's him look older, which he needed to do I think. It only helped him.

 

Wow, I never noticed how different he looks! He looks a bit better now, I think. More grown up, more secure, more muscles...
I'm not into boys, but I'm sure I would like Hayden if I was.



Star Wars is one
/LM

 

So, the general consensus is that he looks better buff?


"Excellent; everything is going as planned"


Oh, and Billy Dee: I meant any more pictures of Hayden, either skinny or buff.

 

Just go to the www.desiringhayden.net gallery It's got plenty of Hayden pics (more than 7000), I can also point out some which were taken while or just after filming ROTS.

 

Could you post some pictures taken during or just after filming of ROTS? That would be awesome, thank you!

 

[image=http://img54.exs.cx/img54/8152/gq042qf.th.jpg]

Full view here From GQ, filming ROTS
[image=http://img12.exs.cx/img12/7303/interviewnov2003011xx.th.jpg]

Full view here Any 'I don't like sand' captions? lol This is taken from the Interview mag.. pic again taken during filming.

[image=http://img73.exs.cx/img73/9049/sga439ws.jpg] Shattered Glass premiere.. somewhere
[image=http://img146.exs.cx/img146/7008/sga517oa.jpg] same place
[image=http://img113.exs.cx/img113/3176/sga771qh.jpg] and again same place..
[image=http://img129.exs.cx/img129/6575/spun158fv.jpg] Some other event, around ROTS (I think before) Check out the neck

Okies.. those are the harder to find pics. The magazine pics are all over the place Phew that was a lot of uploading..