Should Spielberg have directed Aotc ? why is such a thing even being debated, Aotc was ( and in Spielberg's opinion as well ) marvellously well directed, do you not agree? It looked fantastic, some of the shots were absolutely amazing, the editing was flawless ( I have some experience in editing meself - I was the highest in my class when it came to that ) and the acting in the most crucial scenes was very good ( Anakin's confession, fireplace scene ( Anakin at least ),Count dooku. give Lucas some credit for what he's done, im sure he would take it very personally if he saw that the majority of people thinks Spielberg should have directed Aotc. This is turning into the usual basher/gushers stand-off, so I'm closing it. If you want to talk about Spielberg, please go to Community.