Star Trek: Dream Team - (results now in!)

Discussion in 'Archive: SF&F: Films and Television' started by Everton, Jan 7, 2006.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Everton Chosen One

    Member Since:
    Jul 18, 2003
    star 10
    There's been lots of Trek, right? Lots of great crews... well sorta. ;)

    What I propose is we decide on our dream Star Trek crew. Who do we all think would make the bestest line up in teh whole of teh 24th century? Wouldn't that be like... the best?

    Well you'll be delighted to know we can do exactly that. In this very exciting thread. Right here.

    Here are lists of all the relevant players, and I ask each of you to pick one person from each category and post your choices using the handy list at the end of this post. When everyone's had their say, we can tot up the votes and reveal our 'Dream Team'.

    If you wish to have people double up on responsibilities, then simply enter the same name in different categories - but you know, keep it true to the show, eh. :)

    Note 1: You cannot pick Jadzia Dax and Ezri Dax in the same crew.

    Note 2: You may pick three Wild Cards.

    Note 3: You can choose not to have a Counselor and you can choose not to have a Communications Officer. This is because not all series made use of these ranks.

    Captain:

    Jonathan Archer
    James T. Kirk
    Jean-Luc Picard
    Benjamin Sisko
    Kathryn Janeway

    First Officer:

    T'Pol
    Spock
    William Riker
    Kira Nerys
    Chakotay

    Chief Engineer:

    Charles 'Trip' Tucker III
    Montgomery Scott
    Geordi La Forge
    Miles O'Brien
    B'Elanna Torres

    Tactical:

    Malcolm Reed
    Worf
    Natasha Yar
    Jadzia Dax
    Tuvok

    Security:

    Worf
    Odo
    Tuvok

    Ensign:

    Hoshi Sato
    Pavel Chekov
    Wesley Crusher
    Nog
    Harry Kim

    Helm:

    Travis Mayweather
    Hikaru Sulu
    Data
    Jadzia Dax
    Tom Paris

    Chief Medical Officer:

    Phlox
    Leonard H. McCoy
    Beverly Crusher
    Katherine Pulaski
    Julian Bashir
    The Emergency Medical Hologram aka 'The Doctor'

    Science Officer:

    T'Pol
    Spock
    Data
    Jadzia Dax
    Tuvok

    Communications Officer:

    Hoshi Sato
    Uhura
    Harry Kim

    Counselor:

    Deanna Troi
    Ezri Dax
    Neelix

    Wild Card:

    Guinan
    Keiko O'Brien
    Reginald Barclay
    Garak
    Quark
    Rom
    Jake Sisko
    Morn
    General Martok
    Vic Fontaine
    Kasidy Yates
    Kes
    Seven of Nine

    ...

    So that's the lists. I hope they're balanced okay. :)

    What you have to do now is pick one character from each category (remembering the Notes) and then present your picks in this handy list:

    Captain:

    First Officer:

    Chief Engineer:

    Tactical:

    Security:

    Ensign:

    Helm:

    Chief Medical Officer:

    Science Officer:

    Communications Officer:

    Counselor:

    Wild Card #1:

    Wild Card #2:

    ...

    So uh... give it a shot eh? Pick your Dream Team! :) :D :cool:



    EDIT: Because there were some I missed out! :D

    EDIT #2: Changed number of wild cards from two to three.
  2. Moleman1138 Manager Emeritus

    Member Since:
    Aug 18, 2004
    star 6
    Captain: James Tiberius Kirk
    First Officer: William Riker
    Chief Engineer: B'Elanna Torres
    Tactical: Jadzia Dax
    Security: Odo
    Ensign: Pavel Chekov
    Helm: Hikaru Sulu
    Chief Medical Officer: The Emergency Medical Hologram aka 'The Doctor'
    Science Officer: Spock
    Communications Officer: Uhura
    Counselor: Deanna Troi
    Wild Card: Kes
    Wild Card: Seven of Nine
    Red Shirt: Mr. Kyle

    Everton, you forgot a category for those lovable red shirts. Need some sacrifice in first line of defense. :p
  3. Darth_Omega Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    May 19, 2002
    star 6
    Great thread idea Everton and this is really hard to do because I want to retain some of the chemistry between the characters e.g. Kirk/Spock/Bones, Odo/Quark, Julian/Garak or some romances e.g. Miles/Keiko Ezri/Julian, Tom/B'Elanna and on.

    BTW wasn't Data always the science officer in TNG + movies? The guy who scans things, while the helm was done by Geordi (first season), that Bajoran woman (various episodes) + random cast member?

    Anyway my list:

    Captain: Jean-Luc Picard tough pick between Benjamin, Picard and Kirk with Archer as distant fourth.

    First Officer: Spock My favourite between the bunch Kira second only because I know I'm going to pick Odo later on. T'Pol would have been third if I picked Trip as chief engineer...

    Chief Engineer: Montgomery Scott ... but I didn't :) Yes I picked Scotty for the accent.

    Tactical: Worf It was between Worf, Natasha Yar, Jadzia Dax. Worf seems better suited for the job :p

    Security: Odo Worf is already in tactical. So I picked Odo, with picking Odo that does mean I have to pick Quark as Wild Card ;)

    Ensign: Nog Easily the best character out of all the ensigns, Hoshi second, Chekov third.

    Science Officer: Data Favourite, Jadzia was close second because I picked Worf. Sadly I enough I don't have Geordi/Miles as engineer so he doesn't have friends (there's always the internet for him :p )

    Chief Medical Officer: Julian Bashir Not really a fan of "The Doctor", Pulaski nor Phlox. So its between Bashir, Bones, Beverly. I have Spock so I should pick Bones yet no Kirk :( I have Picard so I should pick Beverly yet I never liked the thing between the two so I went for Bashir.

    Helm: Hikaru Sulu I'm not sure if I'm allowed to pick Data again and because I picked Bashir I need to have Ezri so...yeah.

    Communications Officer: Uhura Woah picking between two under developed characters how hard. I like Uhura's voice better :p

    Counselor: Ezri Dax I picked Bashir so I need to have Ezri.

    Wild Card #1: Quark No brainer, I have Odo so I need to pick Quark

    Wild Card #2: Garak No brainer, I have Bashir so I need to pick Garak

    Wild Card #3: Guinan Tough pick, between Guinan, Morn and Rom.


    Woah this was harder then I expected. I think I screwed with medical and helm because of my fanboyism with Bashir/Ezri Dax (in my defence I was hoping for Bashir/Dax couple since I started watching DS9 as a 9 year old). Also by picking Data and Bashir I should have picked Miles as Chief Engineer but fake accents are cool.

    Some suggestions:
    add Hoshi to comm officer
    add Jake to wild card
    add Barclay to wild card
    add Morn to wild card (hey he appeared in more episodes then Nog!)
    add Martok to wild card

    Also add a bad guy section, because I really want to pick a Jeffrey Combs character such a great Trek actor.

    Ah well that was fun to do :p
  4. Everton Chosen One

    Member Since:
    Jul 18, 2003
    star 10
    I agree with your modifications Omega. I'll edit them in. :)

    EDIT: Bad Guys are gonna come later... depending on how successful this is to begin with.

    Also, since the wild cards section is growing, let's up the quota to three.
  5. Darth_Omega Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    May 19, 2002
    star 6
    Ok cool :) So...where's your dream team Everton? :D
  6. NJOfan215 Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    May 17, 2003
    star 5
    Benjamin Sisko - captain
    Spock - first officer
    Geordi - engineer
    Malcolm - tactical/security
    Data - science
    JAdzia Dax - helm
    Nog - Ensign
    EMH - doctor
    Troi - counsoler
    Garek - wildcard
    Bashir - wildcard ( i think he should be able to count as one since i think he would be a good all around character because of his genetic engineering)



  7. Honor_And_Liberty Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Nov 1, 2005
    star 1
    Captain:

    Benjamin Sisko

    First Officer:

    Spock

    Chief Engineer:

    Miles O'Brien

    Tactical:

    Worf

    Security:

    Odo

    Ensign:

    Nog

    Helm:

    Data

    Chief Medical Officer:

    The Emergency Medical Hologram aka 'The Doctor'

    Science Officer:

    Jadzia Dax

    Communications Officer:

    None!

    Counselor:

    None!!

    Wild Card:

    Reginald Barclay
    Garak
    Morn


    Tough choices. :p
  8. Everton Chosen One

    Member Since:
    Jul 18, 2003
    star 10
    Captain: Jean-Luc Picard - because he's the very definition of authority.

    First Officer: William T. Riker - I think the relationship between him and Picard is the best Captain / First Officer relationship of the lot.

    Chief Engineer: Miles O'Brien - He's gritty, he's real, and has a good line in "Bloody Hell!" :p

    Tactical: Tuvok - I think he's the best Vulcan ever. Yes, Spock is Spock, but Tuvok is really great IMO.

    Security: Odo - Because he always gets his man, and had the charm to tame Kira.

    Ensign: Nog - because I think he showed the best development over a series run of any character. Unexpected and delightful.

    Helm: Tom Paris - Best pilot there is! If I needed anyone to pilot my Starship out of a tricky patch... it would be him.

    Chief Medical Officer: The EMH - Hilarious.

    Science Officer: Data - So that Spot could be onboard. A ship needs a cat.

    Communications Officer: Hoshi Sato - Because I really like the thing Uhura and her wore in their ears... but Sato is hotter.

    Counselor: My crew doesn't need one. If there's an emergency, the Doctor can work his magic. :D

    Wild Card #1: Guinan - As mysterious as they come.

    Wild Card #2: Garak - Ditto Guinan... but when necessary he can jettison his morals; something most Starfleet officers cannot do.

    Wild Card #3: Rom - Because he really tries... and it's possible Leeta might come along. ;)
  9. Darth_Duck Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    Oct 13, 2000
    star 4
    Captain: Benjamin Lafayette Sisko
    First Officer: William Thomas Riker
    Chief Engineer: Miles Edward O'Brien
    Tactical: Tuvok
    Security: Worf Rozhenko, son of Mogh
    Helm: Ro Laren
    Chief Medical Officer: Dr. Julian Subatoi Bashir
    Science Officer: Jadzia Dax
    Communications Officer: Harry S.L. Kim
    Counselor: Deanna Troi
    Wild Card #1: Keiko O'Brien
    Wild Card #2: Jake Sisko
    Wild Card #3: Guinan
  10. malcolm-darth-am-i Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    May 21, 2005
    star 4

    Captain: Archer

    First Officer: Spock

    Chief Engineer: B'Elanna Torres

    Tactical: Malcolm Reed (we share the same first name :))

    Security: Odo

    Ensign: Harry Kim

    Helm: Tom Paris

    Chief Medical Officer: The Doctor

    Science Officer: Data

    Communications Officer: Hoshi Sato

    Counselor: Deanna Troi

    Wild Card #1: Quark

    Wild Card #2: Seven of Nine

    Wild Card #3: General Martok
  11. Darth_Omega Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    May 19, 2002
    star 6
    I guess I'm the only who hates the EMH? [face_worried]
  12. malcolm-darth-am-i Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    May 21, 2005
    star 4
    How can you not like the Doc.(Joe) that is the name he picked for himself in Endgame. The Doc is so funny. He has the best bed side manner.
  13. Everton Chosen One

    Member Since:
    Jul 18, 2003
    star 10
    :cool: @ the middle names. :p

    EDIT: And yeah Ro Laren needs to be an option for Helm.
  14. Ace_Venom Jedi Knight

    Member Since:
    Sep 22, 2002
    star 3
    Captain: James Tiberius Kirk
    Come on. He was the best captain.

    First Officer: Spock
    Live long and prosper.

    Chief Engineer: Geordi La Forge
    I would have gone with Scotty, but Geordi is more familiar with later engineering designs.

    Tactical/Security: Tuvok
    When you need Vulcan precision to get the job done, call Tuvok.

    Ensign/Communications Officer: Hoshi Sato
    This is really a no brainer for an exploration mission.

    Helm: Hikaru Sulu
    How can we leave out George Takei?

    Chief Medical Officer: Leonard H. McCoy
    A doctor, not a dictionary. You need him to complete the chemistry with Spock and Kirk.

    Science Officer: Data
    Not fit for being XO, but he's still very competent and would work well with Spock.

    Counselor: Deanna Troi
    Hey, this is a no brainer.

    Wild Card #1: Seven of Nine
    She's got some uses in engineering, medicine and other fields.

    Wild Card #2: Reginald Barclay

    Wild Card #3: Quark
    Everybody needs a Ferengi on board.
  15. TheProphetOfSullust Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    Dec 10, 2003
    star 4
    Captain: Benjamin Lafayette Sisko. He is DS9.
    First Officer: Spock. Tough pick between him and Kira, but the scene with the punk on the bus in The Voyage Home is my favorite in all of Trek.
    Chief Engineer: Montgomery Scott. Here, it's not even close.
    Tactical: Worf
    Security: Worf. I like Odo, but the ability to shapeshift makes some things too easy for him.
    Ensign: Nog. I don't like Wesley, Chekov never interested me, and I haven't watched enough of Voyager to get attached to any characters.
    Helm: Sulu. Although I liked him more as a captain in The Undiscovered Country.
    Chief Medical Officer: Beverly Howard Crusher. Sorry, McCoy.
    Science Officer: Jadzia Dax. Why did they have to kill her? (I know. Terry Farrel wanted to leave the show. :mad:
    Communications Officer: Uhura. Didn't watch enough Voyager... didn't watch any Enterprise
    Counselor: Deanna Troi. Although, to be honest, I don't see a reason to have a counselor at all.
    Wild Card: Ro Laren. Sure, canonly she's probably dead, but I liked the couple of episodes with her.
    Wild Card: Garak. "But the question, Doctor, is just who is guilty of what?"
    Wild Card: Sarek. Don't ask why.
  16. malcolm-darth-am-i Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    May 21, 2005
    star 4
    Hey I think we should add ships too. I mean what are you gonna do with a Fantasy Crew if there is no ship?

    Ships
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NX-01 (Enterprise series)
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701 (OS)
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701B (Movie)
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701C (Movie)
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701D (TNG)
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701E (Movie)
    U.S.S. Voyager NCC-74656 (Voyager)
    U.S.S. Defiant NX-74205 (DS9)
    Deep Space Nine


    Ship:

    Captain:

    First Officer:

    Chief Engineer:

    Tactical:

    Security:

    Ensign:

    Helm:

    Chief Medical Officer:

    Science Officer:

    Communications Officer:

    Counselor:

    Wild Card:

    Wild Card:

    Wild Card:

    Hope you dont mind me adding this Everton. But Trek aint Trek with no ships.
  17. jaina_clan_solo Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    Dec 14, 2005
    star 4
    Hmm... this is going to be a difficult one... I like too many of these characters!!!

    Ship: USS Voyager

    Captain: Picard, he truely is the best ST captain.

    First Officer: Chakotay, I really like the whole 'renegade' thing. This was a hard decision though.. what with Spock, Riker, T'Pol all in the running...

    Chief Engineer: Umm... umm... choose one... 'Trip' Tucker (sorry Scotty, you were second)

    Tactical: Worf

    Security: Tuvok

    Ensign: Harry Kim

    Helm: Tom Paris

    Chief Medical Officer: Dr. 'Bones McCoy

    Science Officer: Spock

    Communications Officer: Uhura

    Counselor: Deanna Troi

    Wild Card: Guinan... you just can't run a ship without her

    Wild Card: Barcalay

    Wild Card: Kes

    (i know there aren't any DS9 characters, but i just haven't watched much of that show at all.)
  18. George_Roper Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    May 1, 2005
    star 7
    I've only ever watched Star Trek, TNG, Enterprise, and Seven of Nine but here goes:

    Captain: James T. Kirk

    First Officer: Spock

    Chief Engineer: Montgomery Scott

    Tactical: Malcolm Reed (mainly because Worf annoys me and I don't really know the others)

    Security: Worf (because don't know the others)

    Ensign: Hoshi Sato

    Helm: Data

    Chief Medical Officer: Leonard H. McCoy

    Science Officer: T'Pol

    Communications Officer: Uhura

    Counselor: None because I only know Deanna Troi and she annoys me greatly.

    Wild Card #1: Seven of Nine

    Wild Card #2: Reginald Barclay (because he's Howling Mad)
  19. Darth_Daver Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    Jan 23, 2005
    star 5
    Captain: Jean-Luc Picard
    First Officer: Spock
    Chief Engineer: Montgomery Scott
    Tactical: Worf
    Security: Odo
    Ensign: Wesley Crusher
    Helm: Tom Paris
    Chief Medical Officer: Julian Bashir
    Science Officer: Data
    Wild Card #1: Garak
    Wild Card #2: Morn
    Wild Card #3: Seven of Nine


    I wanted to include Jadzia, but she was my 2nd choice in 3 different categories.
    And yes, I don't find Wesley annoying. Plus, he had more interesting stories than the other Ensigns.
    Morn just cracks me up:p
  20. Jedi_Keiran_Halcyon Jedi Grand Master

    Member Since:
    Dec 17, 2000
    star 6
    TIME TO CHEAT.

    Captain: Kirk
    1st Officer: Picard (cause he's man enough to take the demotion and still be badass)
    Chief Engineer: Scotty
    Tactical: Worf
    Security: Data (just because I like him)
    Ensign: Chekhov
    Helm: Sulu
    Chief Medical Officer: Bones
    Science Officer: Spock
    Communications: Uhura
    Counselor: Troi
    Wildcard: Saavik
  21. Sara_Kenobi Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    Sep 21, 2000
    star 7
    Captain: Jean-Luc Picard

    First Officer: William T. Riker

    Chief Engineer: Montgomery Scott

    Tactical: Worf

    Security: Tuvok

    Ensign: Harry Kim


    Helm: Data

    Chief Medical Officer: The Emergency Medical Hologram aka 'The Doctor'

    Science Officer: Jadzia Dax

    Communications Officer: Uhura

    Counselor: Deanna Troi

    Wild Card #1: Guinan

    Wild Card #2: Quark

  22. RK_Striker_JK_5 Force Ghost

    Member Since:
    Jul 2, 2003
    star 7
    Heh. I love topics like this.

    Ship: Enterprise-E. The most badass Starfleet ship built yet.

    Captain: James T. Kirk. Before him, the Klingons had no word for surrender. And he'd probably be able to talk Q into suicide.

    First Officer: William T. Riker. strategically savvy and definitely able to hold a crew together.

    Chief Engineer: Scotty. he wrote the book on Starfleet engineering-literally.

    Tactical: Worf, son of Mogh. Who else would you want firing weapons than a Klingon?

    Security: Odo: Able to deal with a lot more than the usual stuff.

    Ensign;/b]Nog. He really impressed me during DS9. A lot more than the others.

    [b[Helm
    : Tom Paris. One hell of a flier. If he was in SW, he'd be in Rogue Squadron.

    CMO: Julian Bashir. Genetically enhanced without the holodoc's atrocious bedside manner.

    Science officer:Spock. Kirk needs Spock. And the guy's one of the best period.

    Comm officer: Hoshi Sato. She doesn't need a universal translator. She is a universal translator!

    Counselor: Deanna Troi. A lot more emotionally stable than Ezri and better liked than Neelix.

    Wild cards: Guinan, Garak and General Martok.
  23. RebelScum77 Manager Emeritus

    Member Since:
    Aug 3, 2003
    star 6
    Ooooh, this looks fun. :-B

    Captain: James T. Kirk
    First Officer: William Riker
    Chief Engineer: Geordi La Forge
    Tactical: Jadzia Dax
    Security: Worf
    Ensign: Wesley Crusher
    Helm: Data
    Chief Medical Officer: Beverly Crusher
    Science Officer: Spock
    Communications Officer: Uhura
    Counselor: Deanna Troi
    Wild Card #1: Guinan
    Wild Card #2: Seven of Nine
    Wild Card #3: Quark
  24. Healer_Leona Manager Emeritus

    Member Since:
    Jul 7, 2000
    star 9
    Wow, some of these were really hard to choose. I changed it around a number of times before I came up with this.


    Captain: Jean-Luc Picard

    First Officer: Spock

    Chief Engineer: Geordi La Forge

    Tactical: Worf

    Security: Odo

    Ensign: Pavel Chekov

    Helm: Data

    Chief Medical Officer: 'The Doctor'

    Science Officer: Jadzia Dax

    Communications Officer: Uhura

    Counselor: Neelix

    Wild Card #1: Reginald Barclay

    Wild Card #2: Guinan

    Wild Card #3: Quark

  25. Master_Jedi80 Jedi Master

    Member Since:
    May 27, 2005
    star 3
    My Dream Team

    Ship:
    U.S.S. Enterpirse NCC-1701D
    Captain:
    Jean-Luc Picard --the greatest captain of all time (imho)
    First Officer:
    William Riker--he is and always will be my #1
    Chief Engineer:
    Montgomery Scott-- Scottie always got the job done
    Tactical:
    T'voc--always good to have an intelligent Vulcan around
    Security:
    Worf --no explanation necessary
    Ensign:
    Wesley Crusher --the child prodigy will be molded into a Admiral under this crew
    Helm:
    Data -- His abilities are so valuable...Strength, Brains and a great poker player
    Chief Medical Officer:
    Leonard H. McCoy-- good old bones...
    Science Officer:
    Spock-- the wisdom speaks volumes
    Communications Officer:
    Harry Kim - not really sure what this is, but Kim was the best of the choices
    Counselor:
    Deanna Troi --the ability to read minds is huge
    Wild Card:
    Guinan -- She has traveled through time and space, dispensing cold drinks and solid advice to the crew
    Seven of Nine -- invaluable knowledge of the Borg, combined with a cute little figure
    Beverly Crusher --A second Doctor is always good, and she thinks quick on her feet

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.