"So basically as their fighting and trying to survive being engulfed by flames they should chat it up like schoolgirls " Yes. One thing I missed in the duel was taunting banter from Vader. I don't know if you have seen episodes Iv-VI yet, but the duels in those movies have a lot of dialogue, and hence, character development in them, rather than just over choreographed fighting. By the way, I looked at some pictures I have, and Tatoinne does have clouds, so I retract that remark. Also, does anyone have any idea how the Emperor was supposed to mask his presence from the Jedi. Or are we just going to have to go with the dark side clouds everything. This thread rocked. BTW, AOTC is on Fox now, and if that would have been as good as ROTS, then ROTS would have been a lot better, if you catch my meaning. What a blown opportunity.