Discussion in 'EU Community' started by The Loyal Imperial, Mar 20, 2013.
Agree with Horsey
Trade-Bait (5) vs. Tosche Station Power Converters (2)
Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Garik "Face" Loran
Requiem for a Draft (3) vs. 266 Squadron (4)
Derek "Hobbie" Klivian vs. Nrin Vakil
The Not So Avenging Avengers (3) vs. Jedi Starfighter Corps (4)
Kyp Durron vs. Mace Windu TRUMPED with Plo Koon (forfeit)
PRENNTACULAR (2) vs. Nobody move! I've dropped me brain (5)
Imperial Ace vs. Asyr Sei'lar
yay for teams again...
Arguments on the first one?
well, i thought that one was reasonably straightforward since kenobi beat kasan, who has historically be better than face without much question. but that's just me, i guess.
Yup. Just you.
Nah, I agree with Trim, though I might be slightly biased
aren't you one of the two people that should be arguing this match?
out of curiosity, though, what makes face even being in consideration with this one? sure, he's been underrated, but he's also never really been considered anywhere near obi-wan's level? suppose i'm just wondering what's changed, precisely?
I don't think I'll be putting anything up on this one, so don't wait on me
Well, no arguments, so Kenobi it is. Otherwise agree with Horsey.
I'm disappointed. I think Mercy Kill upped Face's experience to be arguably better than he has so far been in the draft. Oh well.
Agree with Jello on Kenobi.
Trade-Bait (6) vs. Tosche Station Power Converters (2)
Requiem for a Draft (4) vs. 266 Squadron (4)
Luke Skywalker, Gavin Darklighter, Derek Klivian, Horton Salm, Kasan Moor, Jhoram Bey, Kell Tainer, Tyria Sarkin vs. Wedge Antilles, Pash Cracken, Keyan Farlander, Jake Farrell, Ace Azzameen, Anj Dahl, Nrin Vakil, Octa Ramis
The Not So Avenging Avengers (4) vs. Jedi Starfighter Corps (4)
Jaina Solo, Kyp Durron, Inyri Forge, Myn Donos, Zekk, Lando Calrissian, Alinn Varth, Dash Rendar vs. Anakin Skywalker, Maarek Stele, Adi Gallia, Saba Sebatyne, Tesar Sebatyne, Plo Koon, Lowbacca, Mace Windu
PRENNTACULAR (2) vs. Nobody move! I've dropped me brain (6)
I actually won a round, amazing.
On that note, as of next Friday I won't be around to argue for my team until early July, so don't ask for any arguments, you won't get any
pretty sure i take skill in the top three, and should also take a couple of others at first glance. and i have better cohesion i'm pretty sure. i'll look at this more closely, but that's my initial thoughts just now looking at the teams.
Wedge = Luke
Pash = Gavin
Keyan = Hobbie
Jake = Horton
Ace > Kasan
Anj = Jhoram
Nrin > Kell
Octa > Tyria
We're basically a wash, but I have a slight edge in the backend.
The Not So Avenging Avengers (4) vs. Jedi Starfighter Corps
I am not really going to argue my match. Though I do think that Anakin/Stele are a far better top 2 (possibly top 4 to boot), and the cohesion on my team is top rate....as well as having some great meld going on.
Go for it judges, don't expect anything more than this from me.
not really sure if i'll have a chance to do anything before monday. if you want to wait til then, that's fine. i'll put something together. if not that's also fine.
Honestly these teams are really evenly matched.
I like Wedge more than Luke so I'm picking 266 Squadron.
I think Kyp is a weak #2 and even though I think the bottom half of that team is stronger, I don't think it makes up for the power hungriness of the top 4 on the other team. So in the second teams match I'm going with Jedi Starfighter Corps.
Before the next round starts, does anyone feel like stepping up to replace our absent judge?
I would but I don't know enough to be a good judge in this. Sorry.
guess i could, but then we'd need to find someone to take my team
Requiem for a Draft and the Not So Avenging Avengers would be my picks... if I were a judge...
well, hey there jaina. how's things going?
also, i shall make an argument attempt tomorrow. for what that's worth.
266 takes it pretty well I'd say -- a general experience edge in my observation. Less sure about the second match, Avengers have excellent cohesion while I think Jedi Corps has the edge down the line -- especially with the top pilots.
So yes, agree with Horsey.
experience edge? really? ok then...
guess i won't do anything then. would have sooner, but i haven't been around to do anything like this. so... whatever i guess.