TV Discussion The Ahsoka Tano Mega Thread Power Hour

Your version is banal and boring as hell. It's just Tarkin vs Ahsoka with a predictable ending.

 

To be honest your both right in JMO. The Sunset ending should not have happened but Tarkin V Ahsoka is boring and predictable (same way Rebels is )

One thing that could have been done from the get go was have Anakin and Ahsoka on Courscant, when the bomb went off. At least that way there was at least a loose reason for the Jedi to suspect her.
Another issue was Barris and her motivations (there weren't any as far as I could see) and not simply use her because she had interacted with Ahsoka and been on screens 3 seasons ago and there was no one else even remotely similar they could use.

 

Yes, I am not sure if the added betrayal by Barriss served any purpose. It could have been another named Jedi character.

 

What other named Jedi characters are depicted as Ahsoka's friends? And are not present in ROTS?

 

Like I said, "I am not sure if the added betrayal by Barriss served any purpose". Why does the culprit need to be friends with Ahsoka?

 

The other thing that the arc did was highlight Anakin's beginning frustration with the Council that actually helped to somewhat develop what we saw in ROTS IMO. This was indicated by his outburst at the Council's decision for expelling Ahsoka. Also, it started to sow seeds of doubt in Anakin in the Council's decisions. I really don't see how you can say that the films gave you everything you needed, when his unhappiness with the Council's decisions in ROTS had pretty much no build up where TCW actually tried to show this. Of course this is all IMO and I haven't watched that TCW arc in some time.

 

As someone who did, that arc and his connection with Ahsoka altered how I perceived ROTS.

 

I can understand the reasons why you blame Ahsoka for the perception, but you also have to recognize that at the time Anakin felt similarly. ROTS explained pretty well IMO why the PT ended up meeting their Jedi.

Cool, but can you at least see why and how it changed by perception of Anakin through his relationship with Ahsoka and how it developed Anakin's character more thoroughly?

 

For the "betrayal" bit.

Kablob said it best:

​

 

I like anakinfansince1983 's alternate fugitive arc idea. Yes it's a more straightforward/more predictable way of doing things but it also makes more sense. After all how could the Council even suspect Ahsoka when she was off planet at the time of the terrorist attack? I know others here have already mentioned that little issue but still.

I prefer that Ahsoka left because she lost faith in the Republic (which is about to turn into the Empire) rather than the Jedi Order itself. I mean I don't have a super huge issue with the arc's ending but yeah I would have made that small change.

 

Screw that.

Madame Liberian wasn't in ROTS. And interacted positively with that Fulcrum character before So by that logic, and Davey's fanfiction desires, she should've been the bomber.

Edit: I hope Ahsoka gets what's coming to her this season.

Remember everyone:

"Justice is balance." --Master Qui-Gonn Jinn

 

"The Jedi abandoned her-except for her Master, Anakin Skywalker." As if the Jedi washed their hands of Ahsoka and moved on. The bold language I think supports your argument about a particular POV and Filoni's Palpatine's campaign to sway public (and fan) opinion.




Cred to starocean90

 

Good God Filoni. Is she your dream girl?

 

cwustudent

What magazine is that from?

 

There's a link under the pic to the original post.

 

Thank you.

 

I can't get over how impractical it is for her to hold her lightsabers that way.

 

Two words: Galen Marek

 

Didn't it go all the way back to Jedi Power Battles, with Adi Gallia?

 

No idea. Never played it.