The American Football Favorite Player Tournament - And the Winner is.... Announced Inside!

Abstain.
Ryan Leaf
Peyton Manning
Dan Marino

 

Seahawks Division

Steve Largent 5, Dick "Night Train" Lane 3
James Lofton 6, Ryan Leaf 3

Rams Division

Ronnie Lott 7, Peyton Manning 2
Dan Marino 6, Curtis Martin 2


AFC

Dolphins Division

Lawyer Milloy vs Art Monk

Joe Montana vs Wilbert Montgomery

Bills Division

Warren Moon vs Joe Namath(youtube)

Lorenzo Neal vs Ray Nitschke

 

Seahawks Division

Dick "Night Train" Lane

James Lofton

Rams Division

Peyton Manning

Dan Marino

 

Sorry, horsey... doesn't change any of the outcomes anyways.

I was surprised that Tom Brady and Peyton Manning both went down in the first round, though.

 

AFC

Dolphins Division

Art Monk- Should be in the Hall.

Joe Montana- IMO still the best of all time.

Bills Division

Warren Moon- Great pure passer, can rival Marino and Fouts in that category.

Lorenzo Neal- Best Run Blocker there is today.

 

Monk
Montana
Moon
Nitschke



that last one was a hard choice for me. Arguably the greatest fullback of all time up against a top 5 linebacker of all time.

Then to add to that, I'm from Fresno, California. So I had clashing loyalties, Fresno State and the Green Bay Packers. But in the end, I'll go with the top 5 guy in the more important position.

 

Art Monk

Joe Montana

Joe Namath

Ray Nitschke

 

monk
montana
namath (thanks for including my link lol)
nitschke


i was a bit surprised to see manning go down in the first round as well, but then he was matched up against ronnie lott.

 

man. I can't believe Ryan Leaf lost.

Art Monk - How is this man not in the Hall of Fame?

Joe Montana - G.O.A.T.

Warren Moon - Simply a phenomenal talent that had me cursing at my secondary for years.

Ray Nitschke

 

man. I can't believe Ryan Leaf lost.

How about, (prior to horsey's vote after I'd totaled the others), I can't believe Ryan Leaf came closer to winning that Peyton Manning.

 

Art Monk

Joe Montana


Joe Namath(youtube)

Ray Nitschke

 

abstain
Montana
Moon - He should have the record for most passing yards in an NFL game but he was hosed by refs even with replay.
Nitschke - It must have been great to see Butkus & Nitschke have to play each other every year.

 

Art Monk
Joe Montana
Abstain
Abstain

 

Dolphins Division

Art Monk 6, Lawyer Milloy 0

Joe Montana 7, Wilbert Montgomery 0

(Not exactly a close division )

Bills Division

Warren Moon 4, Joe Namath 3

Ray Nitschke 6, Lorenzo Neal 1


Patriots Division

Ken Norton Jr. vs Mike Nugent

Orlando Pace vs Walter Payton

Jets Division

William "The Refrigerator" Perry vs Adrian Peterson

Shaun Phillips vs Clinton Portis

 

Norton
Payton
Peterson
Portis

 

Mike Nugent

Walter Payton

William "The Refrigerator" Perry

Clinton Portis

 

Ken Norton Jr.

Walter Payton

Adrian Peterson

Shaun Phillips

 

Patriots Division

Ken NorPace vs ton Jr.- Hey, his dad beat Ali....

Walter Payton

Jets Division

Adrian Peterson

Shaun Phillips

 

Norton - There are kickers on this list?
Sweetness
Perry - Unless Peterson joins a wrestlemania or has his own GI Joe action figure I'm sticking with the Fridge
abstain

 

Mike Nugent - Buckeye!

Orlando Pace - Buckeye!

William "The Refrigerator" Perry - Ate a ton of Buckeyes!

Clinton Portis

 

Ken Norton Jr.

Walter Payton

William "The Refrigerator" Perry

Clinton Portis

:snoopy

 

Ken Norton Jr.

Walter Payton

William "The Refrigerator" Perry

Clinton Portis

 

Norton
Payton
Peterson
Portis

 

norton
payton
fridge
phillips

 

Patriots Division

Mike Nugent
Walter Payton

Jets Division

Adrian Peterson
Clinton Portis