Amazing that someone can claim to be a true, die-hard fan of these movies and yet would state "Anakin and Luke are the same." They are NOTHING alike. Darth Geist: Excellent posts. You arguments are 100% correct. And you are also answering the counter points accurately. This was hilarious though: Darth Geist said: "The Jedi have grown up with each other since birth and they can't even make a plan???" Of course they had a plan... 1) Sneak in by the hundred. 2) Let everyone know we're there. 3) Patiently wait for the enemy's reinforcements. 3a) Neglect to coordinate with our own reinforcements. 4) Do something about the hostage. I don't know, free him or something. 5) Everybody scatter, and run around willy-nilly hitting things with swords. 6) Once our casualties exceed 80%, gather in the most vulnerable spot we can find. 7) Stay there as more enemies continue pouring in. 8) Die. Seriously; Beetle Bailey could've planned a better strategy. LOL! Hilarious.