Discussion in 'Live Action, Clone Wars & Classics' started by Barriss_Coffee, Mar 11, 2012.
LOL Nice font abuse HJ
Abuse is my middle name, dude.
I thought it was "In a sexual way"? Or is that something else?
Ah yes, that was my signature. Don't give me any ideas.
This gripe still stands.
lord kowak demand ranking topic for brothers sequel
Are Yoda and Mace Windu not the highest ranking Jedi anymore because they're not sitting in a circle on Coruscant or something?
Are the rest of the Jedi not entitled to voice their opinions and plot a course of action? No wonder the Council fell - they never listened to each other. Yoda and Mace are part of the Council, they're not the Council. Look what happened: Obi-Wan got his ass handed to him. If some other Masters volunteered to help Kenobi and actually left the Temple for once this wouldn't continually occur.
Yoda and Mace weren't the only ones in the room when the decision was made.
Yarael Poof: Oh! So it's a council now!? It's not just the two of you?
Uh...okay. The only difference is still whether or not they're sitting in a circle on Coruscant. The Council is the Council.
Perhaps there was simply no time to call a proper Council meeting if other Masters were off-world? (Just because they weren't in the scene you can't say they were at the Temple ) I doubt Maul would have waited around for the Council to find time to gather in the midst of a war.
I'd have to watch the scene again but didn't Yoda just make the decision despite Mace's objections?
"In charge I am, shut up you will"
Ki-Adi and Plo are there via holocomm but they don't say a thing.
*Ki-Adi and Plo nod in agreement and end their transmissions.
Wow, reading through this thread again...memories man, memories