Full Series The Clone Wars - Episode 5.1 - Revival - discussion thread

Only if we do so without reason and without seeing what they do with the episode.

 

But we have a reason: She was killed in Obsession, and her death here would invalidate that story, as well as defang Grievous even further.

 

Careful.

And as a general reminder, spoilers for this episode must be blocked out until after it airs, although I thought that would be obvious.

 

im not a blindhater my eyesight is perfectly fine

 

Will Revival reference The Sith Hunters? And has anyone read TSH?

 

Blind haters would be people who hate it before seeing it and considering the story, and never do so.
I'm not saying there isn't a reason to be annoyed, there is.

 

Then I guess I am a blind hater for being perfectly happy with the old Clone Wars timeline and wanting nothing to do with TCW.

 

i have and it was a good read

 

I am current with Shadow Conspiracy, but not The Sith Hunters... seems those @ T.F.N. who've read and love it so much, are keeping the spoilers all to themselves. Anyways, the 3rd issue which comes out on the 26th will be featuring

Spoiler

Obi Wan Kenobi.

.

EDIT: Found Malachi's short TSH review in The Lit!

 

Is Henry Gilroy involved in this comic? If he's involved in the TCW arc, my expectations will go up.

Can we please cut the blind hater chatter? It's not contributing to the thread.

 

If they show a foreshadow of Episode IV in Season 3, they should do a flashback in Season 5.

 

Yes, Henry Gilroy and Steven Melching are attributed writers and Dave Filoni did the cover art

 

Better not make people feel unwelcome.

 

I am clearly unwelcome here.

 

Did someone say that? Personally, I'm sad to see Obsession get curb-stomped, but I'll live.

 

It's irrelevant at the moment, but there was a discussion of what "blind hater" meant. And the answer to the question is no.

 

And in that same series Ladies and gentlemen, we learn what happens to Alpha(who was originally supposed to be in this cartoon until Lucas found the most depressingly stupid reason to exclude him) Asaj and Adi.

Let's see how the new series craps on this while at the same exact time continuing to bring Grievous down.

 

And in that same series Ladies and gentlemen, we learn what happens to Alpha(who was originally supposed to be in this cartoon until Lucas found the most depressingly stupid reason to exclude him) Asaj and Adi.[/quote]

But if they had included Alpha, you would still be angry, because they'd probably change him, too.
I'm worried about Adi, but I have no problem with Assaj's changes TCW.

 

Zeta, we've made it clear that you are perfectly welcome to express how much you hate TCW. However, I fail to see how poking your head to extend the "blind haters" discussion way past its due date is helping anything here.

SpecialOps was already warned.

Next person who keeps the "blind haters" discussion going will be banned.

 

Rex pretty much is Alpha, minus being built like a tank.

 

Awesome. Well, we knew (I think) that Melching has become the head writer, or am I getting confused? I wonder if Gilroy is going to get writing credit for S5 and I wonder if they hired him back.

 

I believe that may be Matt Michnovetz (Umbara, Citadel)

 

Oh Michnovetz, right. That's correct.

Oh, right - Melching had a bunch of good episodes in S1, a couple in S2, and then nothing until the Slaves arc in S4.

 

It's just a God dang show.

 

And the next Obsession target is Oppo Rancsis once he comes.