About C.S. Lewis, much greater minds than his (Descartes, Pascal) couldn't make a logical case for Christianity. Small wonder that he failed too. That's clearly only your opinion. Hardly justification for calling him "thoroughly debunked." Jabba- 1) the story of Jesus' crucifiction is not defamatory against Jews, if true. If true it's just history. But its historicity is a hotly contested point, even among Christians, many of whom believe that the "truth" of the New Testament is of an allegorical nature. Bubba(restating Jabba's argument)- - Historical claims about Jews doing bad things aren't anti-Semitic if they're true. - The historical claims of the NT can't be verified. Seems alot like the same argument to me. Jabba- I never once argued in any of my posts that the ahistoricity of the gospels is proof that Mel Gibson's film is anti-Semitic. And Bubba never once suggested that you did. Read more carefully.