Discussion in 'Literature' started by Todd the Jedi, May 17, 2010.
Satlele doesn't seem like a chubby chaser to me
If you make a fat Jedi Knight, she seems at least somewhat fond of you Probably only in a master-student sort of way, but with the added feedbag...
Were there any Allana pictures?
yes, with wrong haircolor (black) as when she is undercover, none with natural red
A few people have indicated their disappointment that the book contains a lot of summaries that could already be found on Wookieepedia. Now that most of the images have found their way onto the Wook, too, I have a question for everyone who owns this: Does it offer anything that can't be found on the Wook? Is there enough interesting BTS info to justify a purchase? Although that BTS info could easily find its way onto the Wook, too, and the impression I got from the Amazon preview is that the ERC's layout isn't terribly unique or exciting --- reference works like Warfare and the Atlas have tons of aspects that can't be reproduced on Wookieepedia, but I'm getting the impression that this isn't the case with the Reader's Companion. Let me know if I'm mistaken.
Just skimmed it, and am rather angry about a couple things:
1) Not paying attention to the novels you're, you know, illustrating? Luke and Mara in the deluge during Vision of the Future doesn't really work with the scene in the novel - and isn't a very dramatic or emotional picture as it is (though I could be just biased against Scalf). Spiceloaf in Betrayal should not look like a freaking suckling pig with an apple in its mouth. Tahl is black in a portrait but white when she dies...er, what?
That said, Darren Tan and Chris Trevas's stuff are generally excellent - just wish they weren't dominated by the others.
2) The X-Wing books. I thought we'd gotten over the idea that they're "lesser" novels at this point - but they seem to have less information provided about their behind-the-scenes, and Starfighters of Adumar gets no mention of being a huge fan favorite.
3) More X-Wing stuff: In the summary for Wraith Squadron, Gara Petothel is said to be Trigit's mistress and a secret agent of Zsinj...which is so far wrong I don't even know where to start. The mistress story is a cover made up by Gara, her loyalty to Zsinj is open, and her betrayal of Trigit based on morality, not Zsinj loyalty.
Arg arg arg!
you are SO mistaken... the comments are worth it for sure with lots of intel and interesting tidbits. also the info about continuity/canon etc. of each story are a must read. even if some are weird, most are cool!
summaries is not why I bought it, art is in part only. the commentaries is what I went for and was pleased with! that and many other functions this book serves that wook does not for me.
Some of the art is very annoying, as others have mentioned before.
@Jeff_Ferguson, it gives a brief summary of novels and companion pieces, but it's great if you want to know and understand continuity. Wookieepedia doesn't always do a great job with that, and other chronological lists (like even then one here at TF.N) are lacking.
If they weren't trying to use it to justify TCW, with a declaration to the effect of trying to make Star Wars like Star Trek as far as continuity is concerned, I might actually get it.
I still haven't received my copy, yet. Instead, I got my gas bill. And with it, a notice that the rates are gonna increase by 23.45%.
That's a hell of a jump in prices.
So already these things should have been included but were left out:
Episode I Adventures 1-15
Star Wars Adventures 1-6
Star Wars Missions 1-20
Science Adventures 1-2
Imperial Troop Transporter
Chief Chirpa Kidnapped
Return of the Great One
The Ice Princess
Does anyone know if any of these fit the criteria for inclusion? I've seen them listed as short stories on various timelines but I'm pretty sure some of them are just vignettes or articles or in-universe documents or something.
The Tale of the Aiwha Pod
The Lost City of Tatooine
Death in the Slave Pits of Lorrd
The Secret Journal of Doctor Demagol
Wanderer of Worlds
The Battle of Cadinth
Old Corellian: A Guide for the Curious Scholar
A World to Conquer
Recon and Report: The Journey to Coruscant
The Kaal Connection
Bounties to Die For
Faces of the Enemy
Castaways of Endor
Alien Encounters: The Shard
Special Ops: Drop Points
Special Ops: Ship Jackers
Special Ops: The Art of Infiltration
Various planet write-ups from The Illustrated Star Wars Universe
According to the notice, if I were to purchase 73 therms of gas per month, which would be $67.17, the rate increase would be 23.45%. Looks like I won't be heating the apartment this winter.
Just leave your computer on all the time, it'll heat everything on its own. I could have cooked bacon on my old gaming laptop's hard drive.
Warm yourself the old fashioned way: slaughter a Tauntaun and crawl inside its carcass. Beats central heating every time, and you really can't beat the price.
Just watch out for PETA. Here they've been stamping down on Tauntaun rights.
How many times are you gonna edit that post?
I edited it twice. Both times I misspelled Tauntaun
According to my alerts, I got seven notices.
what does the book have to do with the clone wars? Nothing for nothing but the clone wars needs about two books to cover everything from video games, to comic books, to both animated series, novels, short stories and the like. this book is about all the novels that were done. my only compliant with the book is that I wish that the added the cancelled stuff.
It must be! I got two alerts from just your quoting!
Just a note for UK people who might have ordered from Amazon UK - I had an email from them waiting for me this morning saying that the order is delayed due to a problem with the book supplier. Looks like we get to wait even longer..
I got that email this morning too.
I hope this isn't another Lost Tribe situation with a dodgy false listing and us forced to reorder a more expensive copy...
I had no problem with Lost Tribe, at least none that I remember.
Always the option you took with the EGW... Order from Amazon US and have it shipped through them. If I recall, it took about a week for the book to arrive.