The Icon Process is Complete! Please Post Your Thoughts.

On the three new ones added, I vote keep original for all of them...

 

Almost same here...KO all three+add Chewie

 

93 and 94 KO and Add

 

KO to the newest three.

As for the TIE Pilot I change my vote to C. It's the same picture, but looks a little better.

 

93 A
94 KO
95 KO

 

Updated!

 

93 KO
94 KO
95 DELETE.

 

Here are my votes


#1 KO
#2 A
#3 A
#4 B
#5 KO
#6 KO
#7 KO
#8 KO
#9 A
#10 KO
#11 C (assuming that one of the identical icons is replaced)
#12 del
#13 KO
#14 B
#15 E
#16 KO
#17 -
#18 KO
#19 C
#20 B
#21 del
#22 KO
#23 KO
#24 A
#25 del
#26 del
#27 del
#28 A
#29 A
#30 A
#31 A
#32 A
#33 A
#34 A
#35 del
#36 A
#37 KO
#38 KO
#39 KO
#40 -
#41 KO
#42 C
#43 A
#44 KO, add A
#45 KO
#46 KO, add A
#47 A
#48 C
#49 -
#50 KO, add A
#51 KO, add B
#52 KO
#53 KO, add A
#54 A
#55 KO
#56 KO
#57 B
#58 B
#59 A
#60 KO
#61 KO
#62 del
#63 B
#64 A
#65 KO
#66 del
#67 B
#68 del
#69 A
#70 A
#71 KO
#72 A
#73 A
#74 A
#75 KO
#76 KO
#77 A
#78 A
#79 A
#80 A
#81 A
#82 A
#83 A
#84 A
#85 A
#86 A
#87 KO
#88 KO
#89 A
#90 A
#91 A
#92 A
#93 KO
#94 del
#95 KO




PS: G-S, you're doing a wonderful job! Thank you for bothering to do all this .

 

Updated!

 

93: A
94: KO
95: Add A

 

Can you replace the old Plo koon icon and make one with him yielding his lightsaber for example ?
Because I think this old icon looks very very similar to the new one (see my icon)

 

Maybe later. But for now, we are only dealing with the current replacement nominees. We will do one-for-one icon switches after this current 4-Phase process is complete.

 

Ok I'll wait

 

The regular page has been updated with new icons to vote on! (May need to Refresh)

List of Replacement Icon Recommendations

And...

Here are the winners so far

 

I vote to keep the original icons for 93-95. I can't see the original icon for 96 though. It comes up as a broken link.

 

Fixed!

 

Thanks, Grilled-Sarlacc.

#96. KO

While the view of the new icon is slightly nicer, it's too oversharpened.

 

What FlamingSword said

Keep the old one.

 

The regular page has been updated! (May need to Refresh)

List of Replacement Icon Recommendations

And...

Here are the winners so far (may need to Refresh)

 

#96: KO

 

96: KO

 

I hope I get how this works...

If not can a mod just take my votes and edit the post out? Dont want to clog up space.

1) A

2) A

3) A

4) A

5) KO

6) KO

7) A

8) A

9) B (wow that came out better than mine)

10) A

11) D

12) E

13) DEL

14) B

15) E

16) -

17) THERE IS NO 17? WTH? J/K

18) H

19) KO

20) DEL

21) KO

22) B

23) KO

24) A

25) DEL

26) DEL

27) A

28) A

29) A

30) A

31) A

32) A

33) KO

34) A

35) DEL

36) DEL

37) KO

38) KO

39) KO

40) ADD

41) KO

42) KO

43) A

44) D

45) ADD

46) KO

47) A

48) DEL

49) THERE IS NO 49

50) ADD

51) KO

52) DEL

53) DEL

54) A

55) KO

56) KO

57) ADD B

58) B

59) DEL

60) KO

61) KO

62) ADD A

63) KO

64) KO!

65) ADD A

66) B

67) B

68) C

69) KO

70) ADD

71) KO

72) DEL

73) A

74) A

75) KO

76) DEL

77) KO

78) A

79) A

80) ADD A

81) DEL

82) KO

83) B

84) KO

85) KO

86) A

87) A

88) KO

89) A

90) A

91) KO

92) KO

93) KO

94) KO

95) A

96) A

 

Wonderful Work Grilled-Sarlacc

 

*96* KO

 

96: KO