To me, the plot, the visual effects, the music have brought Star Wars back to the OT level. I love the CG elements from the latest trailer. I love the ship designs, the costumes, the sets, the colors used on Geonosis. The sets on Kamino. The asteroid chase, the final battle. The camera work. It all looks like a vast improvement over TPM. But I'm still torn. I hate nearly eveything I've heard from the dialogue. I think Natalie's and Hayden's acting and dialogue in the romantic scenes is going to be the absolute low point of the series, with the possible exception of Jar Jar in TPM. My main hope is that those scenes will be short, that the focus will be on Natalie's beauty and the romantic settings rather than her spoken dialogue. She is truly the weakest link in the cast, and that really bothers me since her role is so important to Anakin's fall.