The Official Social and Philosophical Discussion Thread

I can't wait for HP! J_M_V, where did you here that Dumbledore dies? He can't or Harry will end up dying an that can't happen!

I am excited about the Narnia movie too!Bacon, have you read the books? I am hoping it will be 7 movies and not 1 movie with all the stuff stuck together, that just won't work!

 

Well, it seems they've skipped TMN, I'm not sure...

 

It is all over the news in UK (well Newsround) a lot of people in the town where HP is printed have started placing bets on Dumbledore dying.
And she did say a major character will die, in this book.
Also Sirius Black isn't dead.

 

What the hell? Sirius didn't die!!! I don't know where you're hearing this, but I think they're wrong

 

Wait and see.
Gary Oldman is signed up for five films.
Why would she write him out of it after three?

 

They can't skip TMN!That was a good one!

You can't rely on JKR! She said that Sirius was an unimportant character. Wrong!

Dumbledore can't die. My sister and I have been thinking and we have pretty much figured out that it isn't dumbledore who dies!

Listen to someting I read. Ways to know that Harrys dad is still alive and is lupin. Lupin never told harry that he looked like his dad, he freaked out when harry said he could here his mom scream before she died,he never touches harry. So there is a spell that can make a person switch bodies. so James switched bodies with Lupin so that he could keep the secret and then Lupin would be a decoy. Only James and Lupin knew about this so when Voldemort killed "James"or lupin in james body, james had no where to go so he had to stay in Lupins body and can't tell harry or Voldemort will kill him!

 

Okay, I'd like to believe that, but that's crazy!

 

Jesus SWB are you on Angel Dust?

 

Gotta be something.... that would mean Harry's dad was a werewolf, and, in my opinion, destroy the plot of Prisoner of Azkaban. And Sirius living would mess things up too.

 

I am not on anything. I am just a big HP fan and read tons of books on this stuff!

Sirius did not die. He just went behind the mirror thing and I am hoping he can come back!

SWD, have you not read the 5th book?

 

Yes, i recall Order of the Phoenix quite well. Why?

 

You acting funny when sirius dying was mentioned!

 

That's what I said Sirius isn't dead.

 

Ok well I have to go but I want to continue this discussion later.I have alot to say!

 

See yah! And yes I still believe Sirius died. It's Dumbledore dying in the Half-Blood Prince that I don't believe.

Oh. I see what you meant now. Sorry, I was just trying to state that Sirius died. Sorry that I was unclear

 

(listens to mix CD) We should have a party for something.... any ideas?

 

I guess I'm the only person who hates Harry Potter...

 

Not your not WLOR,I do to
This is the first time i posted in here

 

Yay!!!

Thank you for posting here, Jango--John!!!

 

Hi, Jango! Welcome! Sorry to hear that you both hate Harry Potter.... let's talk LOTR then... What is y'all's favorite book and movie of LOTR? I liked The Fellowship for books and ROTK for movies.

 

FOTR, FOTR.

 

Right along there with you, SWdude.

FOTR for books, ROTK for movies. It deserved every Oscar it got, and then some.

 

Honestly i have not read the books.But,ROTK i think was the best movie.

 

JJ, you have to read the books!!!

 

The only thing I didn't like about the book of FOTR was that unti the movie, I was confused about how the whole Sauron thing worked, and how his eye could still be alive. unfortunately, i was in fifth grade when I read the other two and until the very end, couldn't see the significance of Rohan or Gondor. The movies, for me, anyway, were a lot clearer. They were perfect, especially the extended editions!

EDIT: Changing that. I thought it was more powerful for Rohan to fight Helm's deep without the elves.