After careful research of all existing Star Wars FanFilms, I have come up with the cream of the crop. To allow the best possible review of each title, I have decided to rate each film in four seperate categories, each on a 5 number system. As time goes by, I will provide detailed justifications for each film on the list, which is always subject to change. Categories Music: Did the musical score chosen for the film match the action? Special Effects: Were the effects used in the film make sense? Sound: Did the sound effects used in the film match the action? Were the actors heard clearly? Direction/Fight Choreography: How was the action directed? Did the film flow easily from one incident to the next? Acting: How did the actors perform their roles? Did they provide adequate, believeable characters, with appropriate emotional and psychological depth. Well, here goes nothing.... #5: Knight Quest Music: 3.0 Special Effects: 3.5 Sound: 3.0 Direction/Fight Choreography: 3.5 Acting: 2.5 #4: A Question of Faith Music: 3.5 Special Effects: 3.5 Sound: 3.0 Directon/Fight Choreography: 3.5 Acting: 3.0 #3: Seeds of Darkness Music: 3.5 Special Effects: 4.0 Sound: 4.0 Direction/Fight Choreography: 3.5 Acting: 3.0 #2: Duality Music: 4.0 Special Effects: 4.0 Sound: 4.0 Direction/Fight Choreography: 4.0 Acting: 4.0 #1: Troops Music: 4.5 Special Effects: 4.5 Sound: 5.0 Direction/Fight Choreography: 5.0 Acting: 5.0 Well, that's it for the "by-category" listing. A detailed justification of the list's ordering will be posted in due time.