Log in or Sign up

main

side

curve

In Memory of LAJ_FETT: Please share your remembrances and condolences HERE

Tournament: Best Star Wars Novel-- Final Results inside!

Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by droideka27, Dec 2, 2005.

Thread Status:: Not open for further replies.

Page 2 of 43

Jacen-Vader Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Nov 6, 2005

Vision of the Future - Tim Zahn

and

Isard's Revenge - Michael Stackpole

Jacen-Vader, Dec 3, 2005

#26
Captain_Typho Jedi Master

Registered:

Jul 30, 2003

Vision of the Future.

I haven't read any of those x-wing books so i can't vote for that.

Captain_Typho, Dec 3, 2005

#27
Mastadge Manager Emeritus VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Jun 4, 1999

Vision of the Future

The Bacta War

Mastadge, Dec 3, 2005

#28
Master_Keralys VIP VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Oct 8, 2003

Vision of the Future
Timothy Zahn
- This is really not even a fair matchup, now, is it? I don't think anyone has voted otherwise in this category yet.

X-wing: The Bacta War
Michael Stackpole
- Hard decision, as those are both very good books. But I put Bacta War first just because of how much fun it was, the sheer insanity of what they tried (and succeeded) to do.

- Keralys

Master_Keralys, Dec 3, 2005

#29
Mastadge Manager Emeritus VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Jun 4, 1999

Master_Keralys said:

This is really not even a fair matchup, now, is it? I don't think anyone has voted otherwise in this category yet.
Click to expand...

I considered it.

Mastadge, Dec 3, 2005

#30
talkingbanana Jedi Master

Registered:

Jun 4, 2003

Vision of the Future
- This isn't even fair. Bakura was okay, but it doesn't stand a chance against Zahn.

The Bacta War
- In my opinion, IR is the worst book of the series. I've been trying to reread it for a while, and I never get very far into it. BW, by comparison, is easily the best of Stackpole's books.

talkingbanana, Dec 3, 2005

#31
Master_Keralys VIP VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Oct 8, 2003

Mastadge said:

I considered it.
Click to expand...

Indeed? That some would consider it wouldn't surprise me. That it would have anything even as sizeable as a 1:10 ratio against Zahn's work would. And you also didn't vote for it...

- Keralys

Master_Keralys, Dec 3, 2005

#32
droideka27 Manager Emeritus VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

May 28, 2002

- This is really not even a fair matchup, now, is it? I don't think anyone has voted otherwise in this category yet.

Yeah, but there will be multiple unfair match ups, and some REALLY tough ones. The braket order is randomly generated.

EDIT: also thanks for the alert about the duplicate... it has been replaced with "Dark Tide II: Ruin"

droideka27, Dec 3, 2005

#33
kopolee11 Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Dec 30, 2003

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

And I'll skip the other pairing.

kopolee11, Dec 3, 2005

#34
drth sidious Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Jul 24, 1999

Vision of the Future

and

X-Wing: The Bacta War

drth sidious, Dec 3, 2005

#35
sidious618 Jedi Grand Master

Registered:

Apr 20, 2003

Vision of the Future and Isard's Revenge.

sidious618, Dec 3, 2005

#36
droideka27 Manager Emeritus VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

May 28, 2002

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

X-Wing The Bacta War
by Michael A. Stackpole

droideka27, Dec 3, 2005

#37
RattsTyerell38 Jedi Master

Registered:

May 22, 2004

Vision of the Future

X-Wing: The Bacta War

RattsTyerell38, Dec 3, 2005

#38
AlisonC Jedi Padawan

Registered:

Aug 27, 2005

Pair #2: X-Wing The Bacta War

I haven't read Vision of the Future so I won't vote on the first pair.

AlisonC, Dec 3, 2005

#39
EmperorSorridom Jedi Knight

Registered:

Apr 2, 2005

Bespin Region

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

X-Wing Isard's Revenge
by Michael A. Stackpole

EmperorSorridom, Dec 3, 2005

#40
Shadow_of_Durron Jedi Knight

Registered:

May 2, 2003

Vision of the Future and Isard's Revenge.

Shadow_of_Durron, Dec 3, 2005

#41
HorranCorn Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Jul 25, 2005

Vision of the Future is definitely a winner. So very cool.

HorranCorn, Dec 3, 2005

#42
neila_nuruodo Jedi Grand Master

Registered:

Aug 3, 2002

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

and

X-Wing The Bacta War
by Michael A. Stackpole

neila_nuruodo, Dec 3, 2005

#43
darth_paul Jedi Master

Registered:

Apr 24, 2000

The Truce at Bakura
by Kathy Tyers

No vote second pair. (Never read the X-Wing books.)

-Paul

darth_paul, Dec 3, 2005

#44
Asyr Handor Jedi Padawan

Registered:

Oct 11, 1999

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

X-Wing Isard's Revenge
by Michael A. Stackpole

Asyr Handor, Dec 3, 2005

#45
sido-diuus Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Apr 13, 2003

Vision of the Future

Bacta War

sido-diuus, Dec 3, 2005

#46
Handmaiden Yané Manager Emeritus VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Jul 15, 2002

Isard's Revenge & the Bacta War.

EDIT:

I just looked at all the rounds. They are set up so unfairly! I will never be able to choose!

Handmaiden Yané, Dec 3, 2005

#47
PalpShouldLive Jedi Master

Registered:

Jun 13, 2005

Vision

Bacta

PalpShouldLive, Dec 3, 2005

#48
Jedi_Winter_Knight Jedi Youngling

Registered:

Oct 30, 2005

Vision of the Future
by Timothy Zahn

and

X-Wing The Bacta War
by Michael A. Stackpole

Jedi_Winter_Knight, Dec 4, 2005

#49
Havac Former Moderator VIP - Former Mod/RSA

Registered:

Sep 29, 2005

VOTF
Bacta War

Havac , Dec 4, 2005

#50

Page 2 of 43

Thread Status:: Not open for further replies.