My list: 1981: 1. ANH 2. ESB 1983: 1. ROJ 2. ESB 3. ANH 1987 (rediscovered the films) 1. ESB 2. ROJ 3. ANH 1999: 1. TPM 2. ESB 3. ROJ 4. ANH 2002: 1. AOTC 2. ROJ 3. ESB 4. TPM 5. ANH An explanation......I've grown to enjoy ROJ more since learning more about Anakin's origin and rise to Jedi Knighthood. It made his dialogue with Luke, and subsequent fight and death that much more powerful to me. While TPM dropped from 1-4 for me doesn't mean I like the film "less." It just means as the PT develops, the OT is further enhanced. And if I were to assign a number value to each film, they are all between like 9.8-10.0 anyway. So it's not like I dislike ANH in the least. I just happen to like the others more.