"creates at least the appearance of division within that forum" And heaven forbid that anyone should wander into TPM and *gasp, shock, horror* see that there are people who liked the film and people who didn't. After reading a few threads, you get the exact same impression. I doubt anyone who spends any time in that forum could mistakenly believe there is total harmony and agreement about the movie. Big whoop if it takes them 2 seconds rather than 20 seconds to figure it out. They are so worried that those threads are creating a division within the TPM forum. There is division in every forum. There are both people who like and hate AOTC in that forum. There are people who like and hate the the SE's in that forum. Hell, there are people who like and hate individual films from the OT in that forum. Thats a lot of divisions within one board, but no one seems concerned. The only difference in TPM is that there are threads for them. Since division exists in those boards without Sanctuaries, those threads are hardly creating it in TPM. And since so many people have argued that one-sided discussions are not good discussions, then I suppose a lack of division in a forum would hurt it, wouldn't it? I also want to point out that SW Community has fan clubs. EU Community is practically nothing but Fan Clubs and has a Haters Community. Yet no one is complaining that those threads are hurting other forums or the JC as a whole. No one is complaining that it gives the appearance of division within those forums, or that they are encouraging people to misbehave. So why are some people choosing to focus on removing them from TPM? And since so many seem to be only focusing on the behavior in the Sanc, it definitely looks to me like that is the real target here.