Saga Unpopular Star Wars opinions!

Eh?


Qui Gon: "Train the boy! Train the boy! Train the boy! Train the boy!"
*Qui Gon gets cut down by Darth Maul*
Qui Gon *dying*: "Train the boy..."
*Obi-Wan trains the boy*
*Darth Vader kills dozens of jedi*
Qui Gon's ghost: "Oops..."

 

Sidious's plan would have proceeded without Vader. However, without Vader, there would have been no Luke to redeem him, and the Sith would rule the galaxy indefinitely.

 

A lot of jedi would have still been alive to stop him (you know, the ones that Vader killed). Oh and Mace would probably still be alive. A tag team of Yoda and Mace could have taken down Sidious.

EDIT: Just realized that with no trained Anakin/Vader Dooku would likely still be around. So Sidious and Dooku vs Yoda and Mace. That'd be a heck of a fight!

 

Err can't edit anymore so double post (sorry mods). But I created a new thread to stop de-railing this one:
http://boards.theforce.net/threads/would-the-galaxy-be-better-off-if-anakin-wasnt-trained.50038719/

 

• ROTS is just as good as the original Star Wars
• Overall, the PT is an okay film trilogy.
• I enjoy the music of TCW and Rebels

 

I think that the idea of Luke being Rey's dad is stupid. I know for a fact that I'm not alone, but there are A LOT of people who avoid me eternally after I say that.

Also, I think that they should have cast a different actor for Darth Vader. Sorry, guys. He just isn't as EVIL as Sidious or Kylo Ren are.

 

^^ Regarding that particular issue I'm a member of the "Kenobi Heritage" camp, until proven wrong by Episode VIII or IX.

 

Spaceballs has a few funny moments, but overall it's just lame.

That counts as an unpopular SW opinion, right?

 

That's what she said

 

No.

 

Attack of the Clones is the only good Star Wars movie. The rest are crap.

 

That might be the most unpopular unpopular opinion in this thread. You win!

 

Do you smell troll? I smell troll.

 

ummmm Kylo Ren's Injury is a totally legitimate reason for Rey defeating him.

Hayden Christenson is a good Anakin

 

Darth Maul is overrated.

Mace Windu is awful for the way he treated Anakin.

 

The prequel trilogy is so far beyond The Force Awakens that the comparison should not even be made.

 

Simon Pegg is right.

 

ANH and TFA are both the most overrated SW films.

 

• Geonosis is the lamest planet in SW
• Kylo Ren is more interesting than any other villain (even Vader)
• Mace Windu is overrated (at least in the movies, he's pretty interesting in CW and the EU)
• ROTS rivals TDKR as the most overrated movie ever made
• The Battle Droids are cool and have interesting designs

 

Jango Fett is cooler then Boba Fett.

 

I agree.

 

I like Jango more too, but I still think he's pretty lame. He could have flown around the entire arena on Geonosis and just shoot at the Jedi, but instead stays on the ground. What a dork! But, he at least had an impact on the GFFA, which is more than I can say for Boba.

 

His jetpack was ****** up from the Reek though.

 

he was too confident for his own good. just moments before he got killed, he easily shot down Jedi Master Coleman Trebor. So Jango must have figured he could do the same against Mace Windu.

 

Not right from the start though.