DFW, TX Voice during the Tuskan Incident

This may be a stretch, but I thought the voice I heard during the Tuskan Incident sounded a lot like Qui-Gon saying "Anakin NO"

I was just wondering if I was just hearing things.

Mauk

 

Yeah, it's supposed to be Qui-Gon.

From what I've heard, not sure if this is in the book or not, one reason Yoda takes notice is that no Jedi up to that point has come back from the dead before...

 

Leave it to that rebel scum Qui-Gon to be different!

 

yah the voice is qui-gon and the book actually does say that it is. i being one of the people who read the book before the movie was actually quite happy that that was actually in there becuase one of my friends wasn't sure if it would be in there or not.

 

and you can hear Vader breathing too

 

That was Vader? I thought that was Darth Chocolate next me breathing heavy and drewling over Padme...


Seriously..where do you hear Vader breathing?

 

Right after Qui-Gon (I think it's Qui-Gon ) screams "No!". It's a long breath but it is Vader.

 

This is interesting I will have to go back ad look for this now....

 

I had said they would touch on the ghost trick in this film.

Looks like we may get some answers about that in three years.

 

I don't think that's Vader breathing. I'll have to listen closer when I see it on Thursday. I just don't see why he would put that in there.

 

If the breathing is in there, then that is a very nice touch, because I don't know about you, but for me, the Tusken Raider incident is the very moment (for me) that he becomes DARTH VADER. He has traveled ALL THE WAY to the DARK Side when he mutilated them.

"not just the men, but the women...and the children...I KILLED THEM ALL!!"

 

DAMN!!! You have good ears! That is Vader's breath almost immediately after Qui-Gon's "No Anakin, NOO!!". It seems to mostly be the exhale, but I really don't think that I'm just hearing it in my head. It's there.

Very cool. I was a bit let down that we had not heard it anywhere in this movie... and nothing at the end of the credits either. At least the breathing is there, albeit faint.

 

I thought it was kind of cool how is pony tail was shaped just right so that the shadow cast on the hovel right before he goes off to find his mother, is the silhouett of Vader. I know it was probably computer altered to enhance it, but even when he's back on camera, and you catch a glimpse of his profile, you still see the helmet.