main
side
curve
  1. Welcome to the new boards! Details here!

PT Was Anakin insane by the time he fought Obi-Wan

Discussion in 'Prequel Trilogy' started by Darth Cyn, Apr 8, 2014.

  1. Darth Punk

    Darth Punk Force Ghost star 6

    Registered:
    Nov 25, 2013
    Was Anakin insane by the time he fought Obi Wan? Undoubtedly. When I look at what might have been the initial point where Anakin first became a ship going a few degrees off course, I'd also say undoubtedly, the slaughter on Tatooine was that point. I'm not sure how the legal system there works, but if a lawless tribe kidnap and torture your mother, and she dies in your arms during rescue, and as a Jedi knight who has seen plenty of combat, and who could arguably make a case to be suffering some form of PTSD, I'd say he has an argument for saying at that point in time he suffered a form of temporary insanity.
     
    HeadStrong97 likes this.
  2. The_Phantom_Calamari

    The_Phantom_Calamari Jedi Grand Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 10, 2011

    Well, that kind of destroys the point of the films, which is that Anakin is responsible for his actions and therefore must be redeemed if he is to be a good man again. If he suffered a mental break from reality, he wouldn't need to be redeemed, he'd need to be medicated.

    The films went out of their way more than once to show that, yes, Anakin knew he was doing wrong. He wasn't insane. He chose to commit evil, for his own misguided reasons.
     
    rdhight likes this.
  3. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008

    I agree.
     
  4. Darth Punk

    Darth Punk Force Ghost star 6

    Registered:
    Nov 25, 2013
    If films corralled their viewer into only one way of seeing, wouldn't that kind of destroy the point of forums?

    Feel we may be at the agree to disagree point of this exchange - see you around
     
  5. Dameron

    Dameron Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Apr 8, 2014

    This brings up an out-of-universe issue for me. You could argue that most action, sci-fi, and fantasy characters have PTSD or some other mental illness, but to me that destroys the fun of watching the movie. One or two to a film is fine (Hi, Mr. Blond!) but for the most part, I don't want to see a bunch of mentally destroyed wrecks lashing out in their madness. In movies, I primarily want to see people who are responsible for their actions and have a decent handle on reality. Movies like Predator or the Abyss have scenes where characters mentally unravel, but there the filmmakers give us clear indications that they've snapped in-universe, not just as an after-the-fact fan explanation.

    You could probably diagnose half the galaxy with one mental illness or another, but for me, it ruins the fun of watching the characters to imagine they don't know what they're doing. I don't like to consider a character crazy unless the movie indicates specifically that something is mentally wrong with that character. Not angry, not tired of war, not self-important or under extreme pressure, but really crazy.

    As you said, agree to disagree if necessary, and no hard feelings, I hope.
     
  6. The_Phantom_Calamari

    The_Phantom_Calamari Jedi Grand Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 10, 2011

    You can see the films whatever way you want. I'm not stopping you. I'm just pointing out that there are scenes in the movie that were included for no other purpose than to show that Anakin knew the things he was doing were evil. I'm not sure how you can explain those scenes otherwise.
     
  7. Darth Punk

    Darth Punk Force Ghost star 6

    Registered:
    Nov 25, 2013
    Never, all the best
     
  8. HeadStrong97

    HeadStrong97 Jedi Youngling

    Registered:
    Mar 30, 2014
    Now I'm confused.. The scene in RoTS where Anakin is shown crying- is that out of insanity or guilt?
     
  9. Darth Cyn

    Darth Cyn Jedi Knight star 2

    Registered:
    Apr 8, 2014
    First, I'm glad to see my thread has so many replies, second, my question wasn't whether or not Anakin could be held accountable for his actions, as he was undoubtedly sane when he amputee Mace's arm and when he pledged allegiance to Palpatine. I just meant he seemed really off directly before and during his fight with Obi-Wan.
     
  10. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008
    From the moment Padme confronted him with his actions at the Temple and Obi-Wan made his presence known on Mustafar, Anakin went into a state of anger.

    Unless you want to describe anger or rage as a form of insanity.
     
  11. darth-sinister

    darth-sinister Manager Emeritus star 10 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Jun 28, 2001
    Guilt. Anakin felt guilty for losing control when he killed the Tusken Raiders, which is why he's angry and crying in front of Padme. When he's done killing all the Jed in the Temple and the Confederacy leadership on Mustafar, he's crying again because he didn't really want to do that. He doesn't want to be a Sith Lord, but he has to be one now. The minute he betrayed Mace, he knew that if he didn't keep going, the Jedi would kill him and Palpatine and Padme would still die. So as he is standing there, he is trying to justify his actions internally while at the same time, he's also questioning himself. He only stops questioning himself when he's in the suit and doesn't again until his fight with Luke, when his son senses the conflict within him.


    If so, we're all in a world of ****. A lot of people get angry in the world. A lot.
     
  12. Darth Cyn

    Darth Cyn Jedi Knight star 2

    Registered:
    Apr 8, 2014
    I mean, even the way he spoke to Padme prior to choking her sounded pretty psychotic, that along with his facial expressions.
     
  13. The_Phantom_Calamari

    The_Phantom_Calamari Jedi Grand Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 10, 2011

    Since when is crying a shorthand for insanity rather than sadness? Anakin is crying in that scene because he's in grief over who he's become and what he's done.

    I'm genuinely curious to know your stance on the seriously mentally ill in real life. Do you think they should be held accountable for any actions committed while in the throes of insanity?
     
  14. HeadStrong97

    HeadStrong97 Jedi Youngling

    Registered:
    Mar 30, 2014
    No.. Not really...
     
  15. EternalHero

    EternalHero Jedi Knight star 3

    Registered:
    Feb 17, 2014
    This is an interesting question. I think Anakin had "dissociated" by that point and split off into an "alternate" Anakin, one bent on self preservation, by that point. So I would say that he was not a person in control of his own psyche.
     
  16. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008
    Oh God! Still trying to make Anakin's turn to evil as something odd or rare.
     
  17. anakinfansince1983

    anakinfansince1983 Nightsister of Four Realms star 9 Staff Member Manager

    Registered:
    Mar 4, 2011
    You're right. It's not rare at all. I run into wife-stranglers and child murderers every single day. Those guys are so normal that they don't even make the news anymore.
     
    CT-867-5309 and Iron_lord like this.
  18. The_Phantom_Calamari

    The_Phantom_Calamari Jedi Grand Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 10, 2011

    Then why do you think the movies insist that Vader had to be redeemed? Redemption is for the morally misguided, not for the mentally ill. The truly mentally ill don't need to be redeemed because any actions undertaken as a result of their illness don't reflect in any way on their true character.
     
  19. DARTHLINK

    DARTHLINK Jedi Grand Master star 4

    Registered:
    Feb 24, 2005
    I have to agree, DRush76. It's like they're saying, "Oh, I could never turn evil. No, no that's just for the rare oddball people. I am, and will always be, good."

    Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness showed us exactly the opposite. We can all turn to some form of evil if all the right buttons are pressed. We may not all be capable of doing what Anakin did, but even the good guys can become evil/morally misguided just by justifying to themselves that whatever evil they're doing now will be for the greater good in the future. Even if that evil is just being a racist, xenophobic bigot.
     
  20. anakinfansince1983

    anakinfansince1983 Nightsister of Four Realms star 9 Staff Member Manager

    Registered:
    Mar 4, 2011
    I hate racist, xenophobic, and I'll add sexist and homophobic bigots as much as anyone, but if you all are putting bigotry on the same level of evil as murdering children who are asking you for help or choking your pregnant wife, I don't know what to tell you.

    No, we are not all capable of doing what Anakin did, nor would we all be willing no matter the circumstance, and that is the point.
     
    Arawn_Fenn and Valairy Scot like this.
  21. darth-sinister

    darth-sinister Manager Emeritus star 10 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Jun 28, 2001
    No one is denying what Anakin did was wrong. What is in question was his sanity, which is that he wasn't insane. He was just controlled by the very power he sought to wield and as Lucas said, the dark side had controlled him. That the Sith who let their emotions go unchecked, will wind up being destroyed by it. In this case, Anakin is burnt and put in the suit.
     
  22. markdeez

    markdeez Jedi Master star 3

    Registered:
    Oct 27, 2005
    Insane? No. He was clearly in control of his actions. Highly conflicted? Absolutely. He was torn between ideals.
     
  23. SkywalkerJedi02

    SkywalkerJedi02 Jedi Knight star 1

    Registered:
    Jul 3, 2013
    No just disillusioned


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  24. thejeditraitor

    thejeditraitor Chosen One star 6

    Registered:
    Aug 19, 2003
    you don't have to be insane to do horrible things. being in a rage or feeling hateful aren't being insane. that's one of the ways people make themselves feel better when something horrible happens. they just assume the person is crazy because that's an easier answer. sometimes it's true but a lot of times it's not.
     
  25. DARTHVENGERDARTHSEAR

    DARTHVENGERDARTHSEAR Jedi Grand Master star 5

    Registered:
    Jun 8, 2002
    "Once you start down the path of the dark side forever will it dominate your destiny." — Master Yoda

    I've been saying this for decades, and I will continue to say it for many more...hopefully. ;)

    Going by all the films now, it clearly means more than people want to believe. I mean, how else do you explain someone betraying and murdering their friends so easily.

    Well, anyway...the use of the dark side is like an addicting and consuming power that quickly and completely takes over its victims mind, which eventually leads to an uncontrollable rage and murderous nature. Thus making its wielder borderline insane. At least it does in the beginning, that is.
     
    HeadStrong97 likes this.