I personally think he did a pretty good job. I think he is one of the plus sides of the pt. We don't get to see him a whole lot in the first one but I think he did do a decent job in it but the rest he just get better and better. I'll have to say his best scene is when him and Anakin are aboit to daul and after when he's telling him he's the chosen one etc. Ya it may of not of been tge best dialog but just the emotions he has in those scenes make the scenes good.