main
side
curve
  1. Welcome to the new boards! Details here!

CT Was Jedi, Lucas' way of redoing ANH?

Discussion in 'Classic Trilogy' started by WhiskeyGold, Sep 20, 2011.

  1. WhiskeyGold

    WhiskeyGold Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 13, 2001
    It seems that in away, Jedi was away for Lucas to do lots of things he wanted to do in ANH but couldnt. He could do a better Death Star battle and he was never really happy with that cantina. in away, Jabba;s palace is more of he wanted to do.
    Thoughts.
     
  2. Merlin_Ambrosius69

    Merlin_Ambrosius69 Jedi Master star 5

    Registered:
    Aug 4, 2008
    There is no better Death Star battle than the first Death Star battle. It's a textbook example of how to raise the stakes and turn the screws in an action sequence. ROTJ's DS interior assault is claustrophobic and dynamic, but it's not a patch on the thrill of the original trench run.

    Ep. VI's majesty lies rather in the Emperor/Luke/Vader trinity, of which there is but the barest hint in Ep. IV. So no.

    But I see what you mean about expanding the Cantina concept to an entire Palace filled with alien rogues and gangsters. In this regard I would allow that ROTJ revisits some of the same conceptual material as 'ANH' did. So yes.

    :D

     
  3. Muzz

    Muzz Jedi Youngling

    Registered:
    Jun 8, 2007
    I see where you're coming from FirstStarWars. Another major concept that Lucas introduced in Return of the Jedi was the idea of a primitive race defeating technologically advanced foes in a ground battle. This concept first surfaced in early drafts of what would become A New Hope.
     
  4. Darth_Nub

    Darth_Nub Manager Emeritus star 5 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Apr 26, 2009
    I don't think GL ever saw ROTJ as a way of 'redoing' SW - it was, if anything, a lazy way of coming up with a story to finish everything off. Rescue mission followed by blowing up an Imperial superweapon - worked the first time around, why not just do it again? Spice things up early on with another alien menagerie, & let's see how that Wookiee subplot from the early draft of SW might work too.
    Oh wait, Wookiees aren't primitive, they know how to fly spaceships. Need another name for the natives... what's 'Wookiee' sound like sort of backwards?
     
  5. halibut

    halibut Ex-Mod star 8 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Aug 27, 2000
    Any more "dissing" of ROTJ will result in severe sanctions.
     
    DarthBoba likes this.
  6. Darth_Nub

    Darth_Nub Manager Emeritus star 5 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Apr 26, 2009
    Fine. It's still better than the PT combined & I'm glad they didn't go with the Double Death Star option.

    Yub Nub!
     
  7. WhiskeyGold

    WhiskeyGold Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 13, 2001
    I love Jesi so I'm not fussing it at all
     
  8. anakinhasamullet

    anakinhasamullet Jedi Youngling star 1

    Registered:
    Sep 15, 2006
    It's funny you should ask this FIRST STAR WARS. I never really thought about it until I bought From star wars to Jedi on VHS. Lucas pretty much admits that he wanted to out-do the cantina sequence with Jabba's palace. And Lucas pretty much admits in the ROTJ commentary that he stuck with the original Death Star ending from the first draft even though he already used it in ANH.

    SO all-in-all I would say YES, Lucas tried to out-do STAR WARS.
     
  9. oierem

    oierem Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Mar 18, 2009
    With Empire Lucas wanted to out-do the space dogfights from the original movie (and make it better). Was he trying to out-do Star Wars? In a way, he always tries to out-do the previous movies; that doesn't mean that it's a rehash of the same movie.

    About the commentary, that's just Lucas talking about his supposed original huge draft that got cut in thirds.
     
  10. Merlin_Ambrosius69

    Merlin_Ambrosius69 Jedi Master star 5

    Registered:
    Aug 4, 2008
    There have been some truly excellent points in this thread! Muzz, Darth_Nub and that anakin/mullet guy, you've all expressed very cogent arguments as to how ROTJ is a "re-do" of 'ANH'. I do think you have me sold on the idea. The answer to the thread question is clearly "yes". :cool:

    I'm trying to think of other sequel-remakes. Evil Dead II springs to mind, and The Fly II. Son of Kong, Son of Frankenstein. The idea is not a new one! Surely there are others....
     
  11. WhiskeyGold

    WhiskeyGold Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 13, 2001
    I think maybe my word of "redoing" was the wrong word to use. I dont think he set out to retell the story or even reuse the same ideas. I just know Lucas was always unhappy with a lot about Star Wars and I believe he saw away to do what he wanted to do in Jedi.
     
  12. Muzz

    Muzz Jedi Youngling

    Registered:
    Jun 8, 2007
    It seems as if Jedi was Lucas's opportunity to realize concepts he had been unable to sufficiently explore in the past due to budget constraints etc. In the 80s, as far as Lucas was concerned, Return of the Jedi was the final Star Wars movie (or at least the last one for a while), so it was quite natural for him to want to pack as many unused ideas as possible into the film, as he may never get another chance.

    I understand why people criticise the use of another Death Star, but honestly, there is enough variation (Throne Room scenes, Endor ground battle) to prevent it feeling like a rehash. It also helps bring the OT full-circle. Narrative symmetry is awesome.
     
  13. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008
    There is no better Death Star battle than the first Death Star battle. It's a textbook example of how to raise the stakes and turn the screws in an action sequence.


    Textbook example? Frankly, I never saw the big deal in any of the space battles featured in all six movies. Okay, I take that back. I really liked the space battle over Coruscant in ROTS.
     
  14. darth-sinister

    darth-sinister Manager Emeritus star 10 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Jun 28, 2001
    To be fair when it comes to the Death Star II battle, the original plan was to have the Alliance raid Had Abbadon, the seat of the Galactic Empire, while the Executor was to be the space battle. Lucas felt that it wasn't enough of a threat, so he added in two Death Stars and then he just scaled it down to one. The battle on Had Abbadon was abandoned since he couldn't make it look like Courscant does in the PT. So more time was spent on Endor, while the Jedi vs Sith battle took place aboard the DS II.
     
  15. Darth_Nub

    Darth_Nub Manager Emeritus star 5 VIP - Former Mod/RSA

    Registered:
    Apr 26, 2009
    The third film of Romero's 'Dead' trilogy, 'Day Of The Dead' (1985), was basically a remake of 'Night Of The Living Dead' (1968). The trilogy actually parallels the SW trilogy in that sense - the second & third films are much more closely connected visually & story-wise, plus the third film is effectively a remake of the first.
     
  16. Boom_Pow

    Boom_Pow Jedi Youngling

    Registered:
    Jul 2, 2009
    If only the Death Star battle in Jedi were even half the Death Star battle in A New Hope. I love the DS battle in Jedi mostly because that's one of my favorite moments in ANH and growing up it sucked that we never got a space battle again until Jedi, and even then it took a back seat to Luke/Vader/Emperor and the Endor sequences. That said, it was always lacking a quality the sequence in ANH had and in fact, no Star Wars movie since has had.
     
  17. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008

    That was the habit of a lot of trilogies. The first story is a hit. The second story is quite different from the first, which tends to turn off some. In order to maintain the interest of the fans. many aspects of the first story is revisited in the third story.
     
  18. drg4

    drg4 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jul 30, 2005
    Yeah, I feel the remake vibe as well, FirstStarWars. It's quite similar to Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade--the difference being that Spielberg's trilogy capper boasted great performances, a more credible father/son reconciliation story, and happened to be deliriously funny.
     
  19. henderson

    henderson Jedi Youngling star 2

    Registered:
    Mar 30, 2005
    If you guys hate ROTJ so much then why are you guys even discussing it?

    [hl=blue]Keep the topic to the films, not the fans, please.[/hl]
     
  20. Darthman1992

    Darthman1992 Jedi Knight star 1

    Registered:
    Jul 17, 2011
    'Kay guy, no one on this forum seems to hate JEDI, just offering a theory about why it is how it is and some speaking of constructive criticism (and why shouldn't that be allowed?). Plus, many guys who hate the PT turn bashing that into a pass time much more than all probably 0 people who do that to the OT here (In fact I really have yet to see any fan that dislikes the OT on this site)


    But on the topic itself, yeah I can see what's being said. I'll even say that the Leia being Luke's sister also felt sort of like a re-tread of the familial plot twist in EMPIRE. That being said though to be fair I think the Death Star was powerful enough where the Empire may want to try and perfect a weapon of its caliber. That's probably the explanation from a narrative standpoint, but from a behind the scenes standpoint maybe Lucas was lazy, maybe he thought it just made sense. I don't know. But on the outside a lot of the stuff in ROTJ does seem to go through previously treaded ground. (Though I still love the film, make no mistake about that)
     
  21. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008

    Actually, "THE LAST CRUSADE" is my least favorite Indiana Jones movie.
     
  22. timmoishere

    timmoishere Jedi Grand Master star 6

    Registered:
    Jun 2, 2007
    Blasphemy. The Indy films from best to worst are: Crusade, Raiders, Temple, Skull.
     
  23. Lord Tyrannus

    Lord Tyrannus Jedi Padawan star 4

    Registered:
    Oct 18, 2012
    Couldnt agree more.
     
  24. DRush76

    DRush76 Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Jan 25, 2008

    Actually, I like the second Death Star battle a little better. The first one has always felt too much like a cliche of a WWII dogfight to me.

    However, aside from Vader's final actions, ROTJ almost seemed like a remake of ANH.
     
  25. Lord Tyrannus

    Lord Tyrannus Jedi Padawan star 4

    Registered:
    Oct 18, 2012
    A new hope was kinda emotionally empty

    Compared to jedi