As I told AJ right after we saw it (the first time). There are no words... The words to describe this movie and do it justice have not been invented in the English language. I was so impressed with how Lucas handled the last chapter. LDV is right, it felt more like ANH with the comedy (though not over-the-top) between the Jedi as well as with R2. The dialogue never seemed forced, nor the emotions. LDV can vouch for me saying "no" nearly in tears right before Anakin kills the younglings. The ultimate tear-jerking lines... "I hate you!" "You were my brother, Anakin! I loved you!" No, I do not think Palpy was Anakin's father. He was a manipulative, evil man, but he did not go that far. He just made sure everything went according to his plan from the Naboo blockade onward (maybe a little before to set it up, but that is never shown). I saw it twice that night. The first time let me experience the emotions and visuals for the first time. The second time let me focus on the story and the words being said. It's brilliant...bloody brilliant.