What if Shaak Ti went with Mace to fight Palpatine and the other 3 stayed at the temple?

If Shaak Ti went with Mace, then Windu would have died a lot sooner. She would have offered less resistance than the three other stiffs did.

Sidious would have had even more time to wipe out Master Windu.

She was so worthless GL didn't even bother putting her in the film.
Look at the pick of her posted on page two...



THE TEMPLE IS GETTING RAIDED and she's channelling Depak Chopra.

All the while, oblivious to the "certain death" standing right behind her...

 

That's true she should have freed up here schedule from extra-curricular activities, especially during a raid.

 

If she had been in the film during the Temple raid, and died like that pic sets her up... Then she would officially become the dumbest Star Wars character...ever.

She makes Nute Gunray look like Albert Einstein.

 

SithStar,

She was meditating because there was a disturbance in the force (4 Jedi deaths) and she was trying to search for answers. She wasn't aware at that point the temple was being raided by Anakin and the clones. Its hard to say exactly when that pic was shot, more than likely right before all the fighting began and after the Windu and Palps fight.

 

I don't buy it.

If four Jedi died over in the Senate building and she felt a disturbance, then how would she not sense all the Jedi/ Padawans and Younglings getting whacked two feet outside her door?

The darkside clouds everything doesn't work either.

(Its)For the better, that she ended up on the cutting room floor. The only death that would have been cool for her was the one where the General kills her onboard the Inv-Hand.

 

Possibly. But how do you know the younglings were killed prior to her death? They could have died after her? She might have been one of the first Jedi to die prior to the big battle, otherwise in that pic of him standing behind her, there would be fighting going on, then I would agree with you 100%. I believe most fans would have wanted to see Anakin fighting Jedi instead of him staring down the younglings with a saber stalking them.

 

I totally agree with your assertion regarding who bit the dust in the Temple,Shiphunk2. I think GL could have made Vader just as evil by showing him whacking young Knights, and whatever Masters were left behind. We already know Anakin killed children, by his own admission in AOTC.

So the kids in the temple really didn't make him "MORE" evil, murder is murder.

Just would have been better/ more fun to see him whack Jedi his own age...

 

Exactly....who knows maybe GL needs to re-think about that. Alot of parents with children didn't agree with that scene being shown.

 

The Temple raid shows that Anakin's willing to do whatever it takes to get what he wants. In AOTC, most people could just chalk it up to revenge against the Tuskens. In fact, a lot of people here didn't think it was bad to kill the Tuskens like that. But here, Anakin's killing not out of vengence, but out of greed.

As to Shaak Ti, her death came before Anakin entered the Council chambers and killed the Younglings in there. She was too busy searching the Force for answers as to the disturbence she felt earlier.

 

So Sinister, did they film BOTH Shaak Ti death scenes?

 

That would be AWESOME on the DVD!

 

As I understand it, yes, they filmed both versions. I could be wrong. But both versions were written by Lucas. It is possible that Lucas had planned to film her death at Grievous' hand, but abandoned it for whatever reason. He then expanded her role when they reshot in 04, so that she'd be in the Council chambers and then in her own quarters. Stover expanded on her role in the novelization.

 

For the longest time, the only spoiler we had centered around the new bad guy, eventually Grievous, and he killed Shaak Ti execution style.

 

Yeah I remember that. Wasn't it after they came out of the fuel tank? They find the General in the corridor holding Ti, then he impales her...

 

What if Shaak Ti went with Mace to fight Palpatine and the other 3 stayed at the temple?

hmmmmmmm then both Shaak Ti and Mace would still be alive.......Sidious too.........

and Luke would actually have some help in the OT........if you catch my drift

Shaak Ti: "okay Master Windu......the time has come.......
Mace: "hold on a sec..........I sense that the Chancellor is baiting a trap for us all"
Shaak Ti: "What should we do? we need Master Yoda.....his counsel is wise in such matters"
Mace: "indeed you are correct.....however I also sense that our methods are wrong"
Shaak Ti: "So what should we do to combat the Sith Menace?"
Mace: *looks at Shaak Ti up and down* "we need a new generation of Jedi"
Shaak Ti: "What are you saying?.....exactly.........."
Mace: "i'm saying that you and I will banish ourselves right now....and start a new order"
Shaak Ti: "How can two Jedi start an entire new order?......whats wrong with us now?"
Mace: "we've grown too arrogant....and the Sith will use the very fight itself against us"
Mace: "we will have children.....and train them for this new fight"
Shaak Ti: "What?..........i must meditate on this"
Mace: "no time for that....we must leave now or I sense we will both die in vain"
Shaak Ti: "What of Anakin....and the padawans?"
Mace: "Anakin will protect the padawans as well or better than we could have"

*leaves for Nar Shadaar*

 

The way I heard it, Anakin and Obi-wan find Grievous with Shaak Ti in a room. She's on her knees and he decapitates her, with her Lightsaber. But I don't know at what point this was to have taken place. I think before fighting Dooku, but before the fuel tank sequence.

 

Yes, but I think that scene was cut tho and later she was in the Jedi Council chamber meditating.

 

First off the other 3 sucked, royally

Actually, they didn't. In the novelisation, it says the three Jedi Mace took with him are three of the greatest swordsmen the Jedi order has ever produced. The OS says "Mace gathered a team of his finest Jedi warriors -- Saesee Tiin, Agen Kolar and Kit Fisto -- to arrest the Chancellor". Lucas said you have to be Mace or Yoda to compete with the Emperor, so Mace's posse were not inefficient at all. The Emperor is simply that good. Shaak Ti probably would have fared even worse than they did, since the databank entry says they were the finest Jedi in the temple available.

 

The results would have been the same. She would not have made a big differance in the outcome at all. The only one who was able to take Darth Sidious out, was Mace.

 

The way I heard it, Anakin and Obi-wan find Grievous with Shaak Ti in a room. She's on her knees and he decapitates her, with her Lightsaber. But I don't know at what point this was to have taken place. I think before fighting Dooku, but before the fuel tank sequence.

I remember these 'spoilers' when they surfaced.

If it had of made it's way into the final edit, then it would totally invalidate her role in Episode 25 of The Clone Wars because Grevious strung her up to die and she was saved by Mace.

 

Easy enough,
Shaak Ti would have easily beaten Sidious With or WITHOUT Maces help.


Go SHAAK TI!!!

 

ditto.

 

Shaak Ti would have kicked Palpatine's ass all up and down his office.

No, seriously, she would have died.

She was meditating because she felt a disturbance in the force, and wanted to know what was going on. She had given herself over to the flow of the Force and could not sense what was happening within the Temple.

And also, Grievous can not kill Shaak, because she is in two scenes. One you see the back of her head in the Council Chamber, and the other, you see her as a holo-image when Yoda is on Kashyyyk looking at the Council. So Anakin has to be the one to kill her, or it will ruin the film. Actually her death would ruin the film in itself. Just kidding.

*~*Ti*~*

 

[image=http://imgserv2.polter.pl/shaak-ti_big.jpg]

And you thought Mace didn't see it coming...

 

only a sith could destroy something so beautiful........such a waste