Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by NYCitygurl, Aug 22, 2011.
Now that they're all out, which one do you like best?
I enjoyed them all. However, when I think of favorite scenes - Wizard Chess was one of my favorites. So Sorcerer's/Philospher's Stone gets my vote. It was fun to see the introductions of the various characters.
After much internal debate, OotP gets the close in my head vote over PoA and DH1. Its close, but I think at the end of the day, yeah OotP is my favortie of the movies.
DH2. Not perfect, but the best of the lot.
I have to say that my favorite is Deathly Hallows Part 2 since I loved to see the happy ending. And I really enjoyed how everything came full circle.
Prisoner, of course.
Deathly Hallows Part 2
I almost went back to see it a second time, that's how much I enjoyed it. I loved Voldemort. Prisoner of Azkaban and Order of the Phoenix are definitely the next on my list. I don't think any of the HP films blew me away though. Which is a pity.
Prisoner of Azkaban still remains my favourite after all these years.
PoA is still my favorite, because I liked how they pulled off the time-turner sequences cinemtacially. Also, seeing Hermione slapping Draco in the face was priceless.
POA, by far.
Hard to say, my favorite of the books is Goblet of Fire, followed by Prisoner of Azkaban and then Deathly Hallows, but the films are different. The GoF film isn't as memorable. I didn't make a vote because it's hard for me to choose between PoA, SS and DH Part II. I think those three were the best of the bunch.
DH Part I will remain to me the best, though the best sequence in all the films is are the Snape Pensieve scenes in DH II.
That was the best part of the film, for sure. I was anticipating it and expecting that I might even tear up at it, and I assumed correctly. I was crying a bit. Really well done.
Joining the Prisoner of Azkaban bandwagon. It's the movie that worked the best for me.
Order of the Phoenix
My sentiments exactly.
POA remains my favourite - stylistically, atmospherically, cinematically - by far. Such things outweigh the adaptation merits of PS and COS (which I consider to be the most "faithful" in terms of adapting their respective stories).
I voted DH Part 2.
However, if this were book it would be a totally different answer.
Haha. Update: I just saw it in the cinema again yesterday! Woohoo!
Hermy slapping Draco in PoA just really did it for me.
Chamber of Secrets, because it's the only one which I have seen.
I would have to say Chamber of Secrets. It wasn't a rage-filled angstfest or the plothole mind field later movies were.
I have to vote for DH2. Only because it was exactly what I imagined, and I enjoyed it so much I saw it three times. But I love that Neville was such a hero and I was very happy with it more so than any of the other films.
Of course, I haven't seen the last film...
Order of the Phoenix. Goblet of Fire is a close second, it is what got me interested in Potter even though I had viewed much fo the previous films.