I addressed that. What's your point? I said that whether the Sand People were in the city or the suburbs when they were shooting at pod racers, my other points in that post still stand. Not sure why you want to hammer this particular point in twice. If you are trying to make the point that it was perfectly OK or justified for the Sand People to torture Shmi because they weren't in Mos Espa during the Boonta--or for any other reason, for that matter--that point is going to be very much lost on me. I'm really not sure where you're going with this.