Discussion in 'South East Regional Discussion' started by Darth-Erebos, Jun 13, 2005.
Please also post your reasons for your answer.
Darth-Erebos posted on 6/13/05 6:35pm/>
So, D_E, what were the reasons for your answer?
Anyway, I voted for ROTJ. Maybe it's because it was the first one I ever saw in the theater, but I also like the whole "final showdown between good & evil" concept. That, and the whole sail barge rescue scene has always been a favorite of mine. />/>
Empire rules you all.
ROTJ is still my favorite because it was the one where good beat evil and father saved son.
I've gotta go with ROTS. It's just awesome.
Revenge of the Sith was the best...just felt closure on everything after I watched it.
ROTJ, I feel, had everything. Capital ship warfare, fighters, lightsaber battles, ground campaigns. ROTS was good, the best of the newer movies by far. But I also remember watching ROTJ for the first time when I was very young. The graphics were good, but the story didn't get lost. ROTS seemed to shift betwen battles too fast. I know he couldn't show all the planets for very long, but I would have prefered he stick to a few and go all out with them. Endor gave us the feel of a prolonged battle. We also got to stay with the group enough to gage the war.
My personal ranking would be:
2. (TESB or ANH)--depends on which aspects I am thinking about...they are close though
3. (ANH or TESB)--the opposite of 2...
5. AOTC (Jar Jar and whiny Anakin factors)
6. TPM (Jar Jar factor)
I like ESB because of all the Imperial scenes esp. with Piett, Veers and all of the Star Destroyers.
ESB Tauntauns, the largest wampa(Darksaber), Space Slugs, Mynocks, and the ever present win of darkness over the light
The Return of the Jedi
Blues Brother to Sidious1
I like ROTJ Becouse it has a(This might make me sound like a little kid)happy ending
I agree with Sage!
ROTJ is the best....i mean what could be better than awesome battles,luke fighting darth one last time,and most of all the prophecy coming true.........i'll tell you.....NOTHING!!!!!!
You know, it's a tossup for me between ESB and RotS. The Empire Strikes Back is an amazing film, but I feel a certain loyalty to Revenge of the Sith because it was the best Star Wars movie... scratch that... the best film I've seen in a movie theater.
Well, I guess I lean more towards the Episode V side. It has Hoth, Cloud City, the introduction of Lando and Yoda, the amazing revelation at the end that contradicts ANH ... The list goes on...
I did vote for ROTJ as favorite though, they all have something in them that I seem to like. If I had to put them in order, it would be something like this:
1. ROTJ I like the completion of the whole saga, which is so powerful. The negative part would be the lenghty Endor scenes
2. ROTS Awesome special effects; Actually see Vader for who he really is and it was very very 'moving' at the end
3. ANH Aside from bringing back happy childhood memories, ANH is very "inspiring" in the sense of hope of the Jedi re-forming to reset the rule of the sith
4. ESB the plot intensifies and of course that surprising "paternity revelation"!
5. AOTC A lot of background info leading up to the formation of the Separatist movement and the forbidden love that changed the course of the galaxy
6.TPM Love the scene between Qui-gon, Obi-wan, and Maul but the rest is "weak"
ROTS. We finally get to see what happend to vader, It was a long time waiting for it. But I also liked RotJ, common is a classic...
In Clones, Padme's character is much more believable as the strong, self-relaint, head strong girl, a precursor for Leia. Costumes were great and there were great moments of humor.
I voted AOTC mainly because it was the first glimse of Star Wars and led me down the path to fandom. . AND PLUS IT IS SO AWESOME!!
AOTC left me in numb awe. After coming home from that moive my life sorta changed in a way. I became the fan I am today. In watching that moive I instanly took to the alien Jedi Shaak Ti and wanted to learn about her and the other Jedi, they are all so awesome. I also had to collect everything and anything I could that had to do with Shaak Ti ,lol I'm still that way to, after 6 years. I was just 13 then now I'm 18.
I had to learn more about the Jedi and about everything from weapons to planets to how the Jedi use the Force, it is all still increable to me, and I still learn new things everyday about Star Wars that I never knew before.
I was wonderfully suprised to find out there was other Star Wars moives out there after I watched AOTC. I fell completely in love with every Star Wars moive and I watch them over and over and enjoy every moment. .even though ROTS makes me cry sometimes, Star Wars always ends up amazing me outta this world with action and everything I just can't get over it. . .I LOVE IT. .and to think it all started with a box of Trix cereal I had to for breafast one morning which contained my free ticket to see AOTC. . .it all started there with that moive.
i loved aotc best movie seeing all the jedi runing on the battle feild . plus all the clones. man that movie rocked.
I prefer epasode 5' it is the best of the saga.
I love darthVader.
who dosent love evil.
also what is up with all the good guys dieing off.
I liked Episode 3 the most, mostly because it has the most action. Plus we see the lightsaber battle we have all been waiting for, and in my opinion two of the best lightsaber battles of all time. Yoda Vs Sidious and Anakin Vs Obi-Wan. Plus since it was the last one made, it seemed like the crew and filmakers tried to do the best job possible.
I voted for ROTS because I loved the ending and all the action in it and because I enjoy the Sith more than the Jedi of course and when I found out all the Jedi die at the End i was Like Huzzah!!