I am not sure what a MS Star Wars film would look like... He is a good film and series maker but I don't think space Sci-Fi stuffs is his thing. No, if that were not Abrams I would have liked to see the Ridley brothers in charge. They know their Sci-Fi stuff and even though SW might be more of a space opera I think they could do something interesting. I am pleased with the choice of Abrams (which was my first choice after Spielberg) and I look forward to see how this new trilogy gonna be.