what would you rather see star wars e III or lord of the rings the return of the king?

i love both trilogys but i'd rather see star wars because you can read the lord of the rings book but with star wars theres no book.........what'd u rather see?

 

i'd like it if gl used some special effects like in lotr but its still good........

 

star wars, i still kinda like lotr

 

whats_a_wookie_: Welcome to the boards, mate!

I'm Ken Kenobi. If you ever have any questions, or just want to chat, feel free to shoot me a Private Message.

Additionally, you might want to visit the Welcome New Users forum and introduce yourself- the folks over there will be sure to give you a hearty hello, and they can help you with any questions you have as well.


In response to your question, I'd most definately have to say Star Wars Episode III. I'm not much of a LoTR fan, but I'm a very big Star Wars fan, so it's only logical that I choose the last installment of the Star Wars saga.


Ken Kenobi- And you have a nice day

 

thank god i can really see them both!

 

This is a tough one. I'm more of a fan of SW, but I'd have to say I like the story of LotR at LEAST as much as SW...


So I guess I would SEE SW since I'd still be able to read LotR.

 

Hell, no contest at all.
If I really had to only pick one, Ep3 would win without a shadow of a doubt.

 

I'd say Episode 3, no question. While I am a LOTR fan, it just can't match Star Wars in my mind. And though I loved FOTR's film adaptation, I have some serious doubts about ROTK after the way TTT turned out.

As a side note, if E3's special effects are anything like LOTR's, I'll be horrendously disappointed. Aside from WETA's fantastic job on Gollum, I found the vast majority of FOTR and TTT's digital effects to be offensively bad. Anakin on a shaak bad, only worse. But that's just my opinion.

 

Episode 3 of course.

 

i dont think i can choose, but if they both came out the same day and i could only see one first.. id see episode 3

 

My friends will probably kill me for this, but... Ep. III. I like the LOTR movies, but I just can't get into the books.

 

For me, it would be Episode 3 hands down.

 

If I wanted lord of the rings I wouldn't be posting here. And welcom W_A_W_

 

Definitely Episode 3.

 

Star Wars Ep3. Why do you ask. Because I'm a really big fan of Star Wars.

 

SW3.

I already know what happens in ROTK.

Of course, I also already know what happens in T2T, but didn't quite get that in the movie...



Rick McCallum loves you!

 

I would really like to say Both but since that isn't an option I will of course side with Episode 3.

I'd like to point out that you can always read the novelisation of Episode 3 when it comes out. So there will be a book.

 

Obviously were all gonna say EP3 because we all started the SW saga and we all intend to finish it; Who's gonna miss the last SW installment that is right between EP2 & 4? It would be incomplete.

So yeah I would definatley rather see EP3.

 

Star wars of course.

 

Episode 3!!!!!!!! no question!!!I'm not a Lotr fan

 

I rather see Ep3 over any LOTR movie.

 

EP3.


Urma.

 

Episode III. I don't care about ROTK. And I'm glad Lucas doesn't use the same crappy, tenth-rate effects that are used in the Lord of the (Bo)Rings flicks. Only Gollum was up to snuff, and that was because the Weta folks consulted with ILM beforehand.

 

STAR WARS!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Episode 3