What's your rating of AOTC from 1-10 (10 being the hightest and 1 the lowest)?

5

 

i would definitely have to say 9.5

only one better for me was Empire. the only thing that i would change is that part at the very beginning when Anakin is talking to Amidala on Coruscant, i felt that Anakin whines too much there, and without provocation, seems kind of out of nowhere and silly. but the movie is unparalleled in entertainment value, eye candy galore. simply the best looking film ever made

 

9. . .but going on 10.

 

I've only seen it the once so far, and at the moment I would give it an 8.5

 

Still 10!

Duderunner: Boo! No one cares what you think, you're a troll! Are you the dude who registered a million names just to trash the movie?

 

I have already rated it (10), but I do want to say that Ewan McGregor did an absolutely fantastic job! I can so see him as becoming Old Ben. Kudos, Ewan!

 

10, wait, didn't I already post my rating in this thread...

 

10 I was very entertained and for as much as I liked The Empire Strikes Back, Attack of the Clones is my new favorite.

 

I want to see it again.
and again
and again
and again
and again
and so on...

 

Well, what can I say. I would have given Episode I a 9.5 after the first viewing, and the second. By the third a 7.

For Episode II it MAY be the same thing. But Un-like Episode I, during AOTC I was on the edge of my seat (nearly, *cough* Padme, anakin scences *cough*) throught the movie. I mean Jango Fett was Eye candy. The scene where obi-wan dives out a window (the crowd goes *gasp*, holy Sh!t) and the clones attacking the federation ships as Yoda commands the mass army. I'd have to say 10... I was just 100% entertained.

Dark|Side

 

I am VERY happy with AOTC and I loved it. Though, I still think of ESB as my fave part.

I give it a 9.

And I sure won't mind seeing it again!

 

A 9

 

After seeing it a second time I have to change my rating on a scale of 1-10 from a 10 to a


20!

 

9.5

Both a Star Wars fan AND real crowdpleaser front to back.

 

I give the movie a 9, but my enjoyment factor watching it was a 10+. I haven't had such a good time at the movies in a long while.

Love it!

Second only to ESB, tied with ANH for me.

 

6.5

 

9

 

Troopsguy is teh suck

-Jesse

 

AOTC 1010321

 

Jessica

what's a teh suck?

 

I give it a 9.5 out of 10. I loved this movie!! Star Wars is back for me, because after TPM I was alittle worried about the saga.

ESB: 9.5
AOTC: 9.5
ROTJ: 8.5
ANH: 8
TPM: 7

 

Up

This Thread is important as a short review style

 

The first time I saw it I thought it was a 10. The second time I saw it I thought it was a 9.6 (though only because I had crap seats and was in pain for 3/4 of the movie). The third time I thought it was a 10... fourth time I thought it was a 11.7 and the last time I thought it was only a 11.5 (small audience).

So... my ratings on a scale of 1-10 for all 5 movies so far:

Ep1: 8.354
Ep2: 10
Ep3: tba
Ep4: 8.5
Ep5: 9.9439
Ep6: 7.3334

RB

 

It's so great to see that most people liked it. Well, I'm off to the cinema again!

 

I hate GL.....He has ruined my life.





























I can't get this damned movie out of my head. 10/10