Discussion in 'Attack of the Clones' started by Obi-Gon_Jinnobi, May 16, 2002.
i give it a 9!
i will give the dvd version a 10 cause all the cut scene should be added then.
As a Sci-fi movie and in the Star Wars context, this movie is an 8 or 9. I really, really enjoyed it. I am so relieved. I was afraid of what another TPM would do to me (probably something similar to Anakin in the Tusken camp.) This is the movie Episode I should have been (not the plot, but the feelings it conjures up.) I was 10 years old again watching this movie. If I had any AOTC toys, I probably would have come home and played with them. I am realy looking forard to Episode III. Until then, it's back to the theater for more AOTC!!
I rate it a 9. What an incredible flick!
My bud and me have seen it twice today and we were just struck by the story and the mood of the film. Why not a 10? I think ESB had just a smidgen more in the way of charcter interaction.
9 great film.
I will give AOTC a 10 because it simply blew my mind away
8. I love everything except the love scenes. Way too short.....next time let them hang out a while George. Anakins demise is on target and I am now sure Ep3 will deliver.
10, an absolute great film.
It was 8.5 after my first viewing - I think I was too spoiled and it distracted me.
8-ish. Good fun, interesting, beautiful FX, but not quite a nine.
"Aren't you a little short for a stormtrooper?" - Leia Organa, Star Wars IV: A New Hope.
A movie has never left me feeling the way AoTC did. I couldn't breath. It was intoxicating.
5. Maybe I'll give it a 6 after seeing it again someday. But right now, I can't see giving a film with such poor acting, dialogue, direction and editing anything more than that. Some great SFX and great SW moments, surely, but not a good film by any stretch.
Seems this movie is HUUGE with the people that matter the most:
All Lucas has to do is cruise, and EP. III should just bring it on in!
A 7 on the first viewing, a 10 on the second. It was a lot better the 2nd time around. I'd easily bestow upon it the title of Best Star Wars Movie. It was massively entertaining, and the acting, script, special effects, music, everything, perfect. With only 2 movies so far, I'm beginning to love the prequels a lot more than the originals. I can't wait for Episode III!!!
plain and simple........10........it is THE single greatest movie i have ever seen.....i will see it many times over.....man i can't wait for the DVD.....
Some of you will know me as being a bit of a basher when it comes to The Phantom Menace, but I have to say, Attack of the Clones completely knocked all those fears I had for the prequel trilogy away. It will probably take me awhile to judge it properly, but as it stands, I'd give Attack of the Clones 9 out of 10. It combined all the best elements of The Phantom Menace and the Classic Trilogy, along with elements from Blade Runner, the Indiana Jones films, and film noir, ande made for a fantastic film. It's great .
I was pleasantly surprised that the love scenes WEREN'T as horrible as I had forseen. The dialouge is pretty bad in parts, but I actually bought most of the romance stuff. I felt the beginning of the film dragged a LOT like TPM, but it did kick into gear nicely once we hit Tatooine. Still, I was VERY dissapointed with some of the edits. Padme in the senate, mission to control ship, the trial on Geonisis, and some of Dooku's stuff really needed to be in there. Still, an improvement over TPM and much closer to the spirit of the OT. (Next time George, less conferences, more WARS!)
I give AOTC an 8
For reference...I give the other films:
YOU bash STAR WARS and you are a mod???
whose **** did you kiss?
be watching it in a few hours.
here's to making ATOC a 100million flick in TWO DAYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
I saw the first midnight showing and right now I'm giving it a 9 out of 10.
I thought the acting, plot and SFX were far superior to that of TPM. Even the bad dialogue that was obviously present wasn't nearly as bad as TPM. Overall AOTC is my all time favorite Star Wars film. I can't believe it passed up ESB!
1) AOTC 9.0
2) ESB 9.0
3) ANH 9.0
4) ROJ 8.5
5) TPM 8.0
*) Episode 3 ???
"you have failed me for the last time"
I'd like to see it a few more times before giving a definite score, but at the moment I'd give AOTC an 8.
10! Oh the cheers when Yoda entered the hangar!
1) AOTC - 10
2) ESB - 9
3) TMP - 8
4) ANH - 7.5
5) ROTJ - 7.4
i give it a 9.5
9, simply one of the best
For comparsion we have:
Oh yeah Padluv, I like the Almost Famous line in your signature.